Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Lessons behind Sukarno and Hatta's bittersweet relationship

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Lessons behind Sukarno and Hatta's bittersweet relationship

This is the second of two articles on Sukarno and Mohammad
Hatta by Halida Nuriah Hatta Jusuf.

JAKARTA (JP): As Bung Karno let himself be absorbed in
politics -- in which he increasingly favored leftist ideology --
the dwitunggal leadership (of Sukarno and Hatta) bond gradually
fell apart.

Bung Hatta felt he was in an awkward position, being a vice
president with no administrative authority or portfolio to help
improve people's livelihood.

"As a private citizen, I would be free to advise the
government in good governance," Bung Hatta told a group of
parliamentarians who came to dissuade Hatta from resigning as
vice president.

It was the transformation from Bung Karno the statesman to
Bung Karno the central player in politics that caused tension
between Bung Karno and Bung Hatta.

The latter had high hopes that Bung Karno would hold onto the
characteristic of a statesman when handling the national crises.
Meaning, he should refrain from any political interference.

But Bung Karno and Bung Hatta failed to reach a common ground.
Bung Hatta's style was management-like, which was to get over the
crisis and restore national unity. Bung Karno's style was that of
a power player.

The backdrop was the critical situation in the regions. The
economic factor was actually the main reason for regional
protests against the central government. But it triggered latent
ethnic sentiments and raised the issue of autonomy.

Some regions began to show signs of disintegration. Both
Sukarno and Hatta felt obliged to meet discreetly to share
thoughts on the best way to handle the regional uprisings.

In their secret conversations, Bung Karno was very convinced
that "another big country" was planning to create an Islamic
state to challenge communism.

On the other hand, Bung Hatta feared that if repressive
measures were taken against the uprisings in Central Sumatra,
they would only push the Darul Islam rebels in Aceh to demand for
a separate state.

Both Sukarno and Hatta agreed that in spite of the uprisings,
the provinces in Sumatra would not be dragged into the "Islamic
bloc's politics". The understanding between the two leaders was
that a peaceful approach was the best alternative.

But the talks between the two leaders were made public. As
disclosed in a letter to Bung Karno dated March 10, 1958, Hatta
expressed his disappointment over the news leakage. Two
newspapers, which had a political ideology opposed to Hatta,
published some parts of the discussion.

Referring to the first and second planned encounters --
respectively on Feb. 20 and March 3, 1958 -- Hatta's letter says,

"Pemuda (March 7 edition of the daily) instantly poured the
poisons from its belly over me. Bintang Timur (March 8 edition)
exposed it in such a tendentious way to punish me. I would not
object if my opinion was disclosed completely. But since it
mentioned only some parts of my opinion, it was done so for
caricature. Seeing such a tendency, what's the use of us
continuing the discussions? As for the ongoing conversations,
which is not yet final and still confidential, there is a 'code'
to be honored."

Bung Hatta was of the view that if the negotiations for a
peaceful settlement with the regions of Central Sumatra and North
Sulawesi reached a deadlock, violence, the least popular way,
would be the last option.

In this respect, Hatta's letter reiterates, "choosing the
peaceful way does not mean the government is bowing to those
initiating the uprisings, but saving the republic (of Indonesia)
from breaking into pieces."

Hatta's letter to Bung Karno further says, "I thought that
you, in principle, had agreed. But the two newspapers disclosed
them as if they were merely my idea. You seem to be passive. Had
you disagreed with the concrete ways I proposed, you should have
told me frankly about your own opinion."

The letter continues, "To the press, particularly to Pemuda
and Bintang Timur, it was disclosed that the government would not
accept (a peaceful settlement). If the government had declared
that violence is the only way, we should not continue our
discussions on solving the regional problems.

"Each of our next discussions would only give empty hopes to
the people, on one hand, and on the other hand, certain groups
may use it as issues for agitation," Bung Hatta added.

Although the totalitarian style of governing had in fact been
initiated and practiced since 1957, it was through a presidential
decree in 1959 that the parliamentary system was forced to come
to an end.

The era, which was formally known as Guided Democracy, was
created to fulfill president Sukarno's appetite for full control
of the government.

The political opportunists tried to secure a place around Bung
Karno. They sought Bung Karno's support for their party's
platforms or to dishonor other influential persons.

The political hatred aired by certain political groups
affected our private life in the years that followed. Once our
family braved demonstrators on our way home from Kemayoran
airport.

As we reached home, the front wall was full of political
graffiti. Back in 1958, my father had asked the president to put
a stop to political groups messing up the walls of their
opponents' private homes.

In one letter to Bung Karno on March 13, 1958, he said, "You
could say that such acts are not proper in a country that upholds
democracy."

The closing words read: "Intimidation and acts of terror would
only create contraterror, and in such a way, Indonesia be
balkanized." Apparently, from 1958 to the 1960s, Bung Karno did
nothing to end such acts of intimidations.

Hatta had never doubted Sukarno's loyalty to the nation. They
both had fought against colonialism for decades under the same
principle.

This can be traced through Bung Karno's plea to the colonial
court in Bandung in 1930, which showed his political beliefs and
strategy were very much in line with that of Bung Hatta's plea to
the Court Justice in The Hague, the Netherlands, in 1928.

They had the same obsessions, to see Indonesia free from
colonialism and become a prosperous nation that upholds justice.

So when Bung Hatta wrote an article in 1960 entitled Demokrasi
Kita (Our Democracy), it probably was one of his ways to touch
Bung Karno's national conscience.

In his criticism of Sukarno's totalitarian rule, Hatta says,
"Sukarno is undoubtedly a true patriot. He loves his country and
he wants to see, as quickly as possible, the realization of
Indonesia as a prosperous country.

"But he should look into the details of the system he has
developed, otherwise it will only take him far away from the
national aim he had dreamt of."

In short, Bung Hatta wrote on his concerns of the
sociopolitical and socioeconomic development at the time, which
showed mismanagement and corruption of power.

Hatta questioned if there was any real action on the part of
the government to develop the economy, or to implement the basic
essence of democracy. The government's reaction to Hatta's
criticism was harsh.

The magazine that published Demokrasi Kita was banned. To add
insult to injury, the government also ordered Indonesians to
destroy all books or writings by Bung Hatta.

To the best of my memory, my father was also ordered to give
up his teaching activities in the Gadjah Mada University,
Yogyakarta.

It meant my sisters and I lost one of our favorite activities,
which was to follow the train all the way from the Gambir train
station to Gondangdia, Central Jakarta. We used to drive our
father regularly to Gambir. On the way back, we would try to
reach Gondangdia on time, just to have a glimpse of our father
sitting by the window in the passing train bound for Yogyakarta.

It was the time the government scrutinized my father's social
life. I remember the big smile on the face of Ide Anak Agung Gde
Agung. He disappeared after he was suddenly thrown in jail on the
government's order.

Oom Agung came once a week to take my father golfing. It was
not clear why he was arrested. But the arrest took place soon
after Bung Hatta attended the royal cremation ceremony for the
king, father of Oom Agung in Gianyar, Bali.

The year was probably in 1962. Some other important people who
gathered after the funeral in Puri Gianyar (the royal palace)
were arrested and remained in prison for years without trial.

Ide Anak Agung Gde Agung was home affairs minister under the
Hatta Cabinet from 1949 to 1950 and minister of foreign affairs
under the Burhanuddin Harahap Cabinet from 1955 to 1956.

Bad politics also pitted Bung Karno and Bung Sjahrir against
each other. Sutan Sjahrir, Indonesia's first prime minister, was
arrested in 1962.

The palace might have received a made-up report that Sutan
Sjahrir or his Indonesia Socialist Party (PSI) posed a threat to
Bung Karno. My father had tried to no avail to convince Bung
Karno that it was misleading to let his own friends --
intellectuals and some parties' members -- be thrown in prison.

After about three years in prison without trial, Sutan Sjahrir
-- accompanied by his wife, Tante Poppy --- came to our house to
bid farewell. Still a political detainee, Sutan Sjahrir had
secured permission from Bung Karno to seek medical assistance in
Switzerland. This was the last meeting between Sutan Sjahrir and
my father.

I was called to greet Oom Sjahrir in father's study. Oom
Sjahrir, who father regarded like his own brother, was then
sickly.

In prison, he suffered a serious illness that affected his
nervous system. As I remember, Bung Sjahrir somehow looked
cheerful. He seemed to want to talk a lot to my father, but the
words could not be clearly spoken.

Tears welled in my father's eyes, reflecting his deep concern
for Sutan Sjahrir's health. He controlled his emotions to give
Bung Sjahrir encouragement.

About seven months after the failed communist coup d'etat,
Bung Sjahrir died in a Zurich hospital. He went abroad as a
political prisoner, he died as a national hero.

A few years after my father died in 1980, my mother confessed
that the political cruelty to Oom Sjahrir had affected my
father's health.

Hatta quoted Schiller's phrases for his article, Demokrasi
Kita. The renowned German poet Johan C. Friedrich von Schiller
said, "It takes a century for a great era to emerge. But that
great moment finds a generation with small minds."

The situation holds true to Indonesia's modern political
history. This nation had waited for centuries to be freed from
colonialism. The 20th century produced leaders like Bung Karno,
Bung Hatta and Bung Sjahrir.

They, together with the other leaders and heroic people, had
contributed great deeds to the country's independence and
survival. But the postrevolutionary era had wanted other types of
leaders. A new breed of politicians brushed aside the role of
administrator-like leaders who were ready to work on the national
development plan.

This showed that our political culture was slow to respond to
changes. There was rejection in the mentality of the political
elite and political forces to transform rhetoric into real
actions for building the country right after The Netherlands
acknowledged Indonesia's sovereignty.

Amid the euphoria, they failed to see the Sukarno-Hatta
dwitunggal leadership, which had served as the country's best
asset for good governance. Sukarno with his great talent as a
nation builder, and Hatta's intellectual trait as a national
strategist and policy maker, should have been institutionalized
for national development in the early 1950s.

We learned a valuable lesson from the dwitunggal leadership.
They had solid commitment to work together, to strengthen
national unity and to materialize the aims of national
independence. When they later could not escape their differences,
both leaders still recognized each other's integrity. They
continued to attempt communication based on their moral
responsibility to the nation.

Regarding the nature of the Indonesian society, democracy is
the most suitable system to accommodate various political streams
and ideologies that live in the minds and subcultures of the
people. But democracy is not an easy game to play, as it needs
strong discipline and respect of the law. In retrospect,
democracy in Indonesia has found obstacles. Parties' interests
overshadow national interest. Anarchy came in the way of
practicing democracy.

In viewing such weaknesses, historical flaws must not be
repeated. All parties involved in government and politics must
now hold unto their respective commitment for establishing
institutional processes. We should have a mechanism that works in
line with the nature of basic institutions.

The institutions are the Constitution, the state philosophy
Pancasila, laws and regulations. When Hatta resigned as vice
president and ruled out any political ambitions, it was a
decision in respect of the Constitution and to the institutional
processes of governing.

In facing governmental problems today, we must abandon the
greedy mentality of manipulating power. We should transform the
spirit of national struggle for independence into efforts to
bring welfare and justice to the people. By getting the job done,
we emerge as a nation with dignity, which the founding fathers
had yearned to witness.

More from 7 June 2001 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lessons-behind-sukarno-and-hattas-bittersweet-relationship-1447893297-1082321)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print