Legislator Questions Anomalies in Sanctions Against Mekarsari Savings and Loan Cooperative
The imposition of administrative sanctions by the Ministry of Cooperatives (Kemenkop) on Koperasi Mekarsari has raised serious questions. Amidst a default problem that has caused losses to members and has even entered the criminal law domain, the government has instead imposed sanctions in the form of temporary restrictions on business activities with a temporary suspension of savings and loan activities.
“In the scheme of the sanctions issued by the Ministry of Cooperatives, Koperasi Mekarsari is still permitted to receive instalments from members. At the same time, the cooperative is required to stop unlicensed business activities and close networks that do not have permits. The administrative sanctions actually create a grey area that allows certain activities to continue without providing certainty to members,” said Doni Akbar of the Golkar Party faction in the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) on Thursday (20/8).
According to him, the temporary suspension of savings and loan activities while still granting permission needs to be explained transparently. Kemenkop needs to explain the legal basis, supervisory mechanism, governance of fund receipts, and how the funds will be used to settle obligations to members.
“I see that the sanction letter has become a ‘winged letter’ — on one hand it states there are restrictions on business activities, but on the other hand it still opens space for Koperasi Mekarsari to carry out certain activities,” he said.
Therefore, an explanation from Kemenkop is very important because it has the potential to create multiple interpretations and open loopholes for the cooperative to continue carrying out activities that should have been stopped.
“I suggest that Kemenkop be asked for information directly regarding the purpose and intent of the sanctions. I think Kemenkop needs to explain openly whether the administrative sanctions against Koperasi Mekarsari stand alone, run in parallel with the legal process, or are actually intended to resolve the problem before the legal process goes further,” he said.
According to him, if the sanction letter is intended to resolve the Koperasi Mekarsari problem, Kemenkop must show a measurable resolution roadmap that can be publicly monitored and does not create multiple interpretations.
Furthermore, Doni continued, if indications of criminal acts are found, the legal process must continue without being obscured by the imposition of administrative sanctions. Administrative sanctions should not become a mere formality that appears firm on paper, but in practice actually provides room for the problem to drag on.
“I think law enforcement officials must continue to follow up on findings and alleged legal violations, and the criminal process that is already underway must continue in accordance with statutory regulations. Administrative sanctions are an instrument of supervision and guidance, while the criminal process has different mechanisms and legal consequences,” he asserted.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legislator-questions-anomalies-in-sanctions-against-mekarsari-savings-and-loan-cooperative-1787223052)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/924005/legislator-pertanyakan-kejanggalan-sanksi-koperasi-simpan-pinjam-mekarsari), translated from Indonesian