Legislator Proposes KY Implement 'Talent Scouting' for Supreme Court Justices
Jakarta (ANTARA) - House of Representatives Commission III member Hinca Pandjaitan has proposed that the Judicial Commission (KY) establish a system for identifying potential candidates, or talent scouting, for Supreme Court justices, so that the selection scheme no longer relies solely on judges registering themselves.
During a meeting with the Selection Committee for Supreme Court Justices and Ad Hoc Judges at the Supreme Court for 2026 at the parliament complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Wednesday, Hinca put forward the idea that the KY should map potential judges well before the selection of Supreme Court justice candidates begins.
“Our experience travelling to the regions, meeting judges at high courts and district courts, we have seen that some are good or stand out. My question is, is it possible for the existing system to move slightly away from the concept of waiting for people to register, towards talent scouting?” said Hinca.
According to him, this step could build a data bank while also allowing the track records of Supreme Court justice candidates to be monitored from the outset. He also said the step is in line with the KY’s oversight function over judges.
“My point is, can we do talent scouting, can we proactively reach far back so that these good track records can be recorded from the beginning and also monitored,” he said.
KY Chairman Abdul Chair Ramadhan welcomed the proposal. He said his institution does want a data bank on judges with integrity and competence from an early stage before they go on to become Supreme Court justices.
In connection with this, he encouraged the establishment of a joint judge examination forum between the KY and the Supreme Court so that there is no dualism between the two judicial institutions.
“If supervisory examinations are carried out jointly, then of course that is where we will see which judges have potential and what their track records are, so this will become one of the breakthroughs as intended by Mr Hinca,” he said.
Meanwhile, KY member Anita Kadir said the current rules for selecting Supreme Court justices are already appropriate, including the stipulated requirements.
She explained that Supreme Court justice candidates need to have an understanding of judicial administration, how to decide cases, and the applicable regulations. Therefore, experience as a high court judge is one of the criteria for the career judge pathway.
In addition, the KY also selects Supreme Court justice candidates from the non-career pathway based on competence and knowledge of the chamber of cases they are applying for. Therefore, one of the requirements is experience in the legal profession or as a legal academic.
“Perhaps talent scouting is needed, but indeed those we have screened so far are people who truly understand and know judicial administration well and understand the chamber they are registering for,” said Anita.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legislator-proposes-ky-implement-talent-scouting-for-supreme-court-justices-1786514344)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5690464/legislator-usul-ky-buat-talent-scouting-hakim-agung), translated from Indonesian