Legislator: Constitutional Court ruling on regional elections a momentum to build democratic design
In a constitutional state, the Constitutional Court’s decision must serve as a reference for all state organisers.
Jakarta (ANTARA) - A member of Commission II of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI), Eka Widodo, stated that the Constitutional Court’s ruling regarding regional elections (pilkada) being conducted directly by the people is a momentum to build a democratic design.
In a statement received in Jakarta on Wednesday, Edo, his familiar nickname, said that Indonesia’s democratic design needs to be built more maturely, with integrity, at a rational cost, adaptively, and with the ability to produce the best regional leaders.
“This Constitutional Court ruling is an important lesson that Indonesian democracy must continue to improve. The most important thing is no longer debating the method of electing regional heads, but rather ensuring the presence of clean local government governance, quality public services, and development that is increasingly felt by the community,” he said.
“In a constitutional state, the Constitutional Court’s decision must be a reference for all state organisers. However, respecting the decision does not mean halting the effort to continue perfecting the quality of democracy,” he added.
He noted that the discourse regarding returning the regional election mechanism to the Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) should not be viewed as an anti-democratic idea. He stated that such an idea arises from constitutional, academic, and empirical studies.
“This discourse emerged as a response to high political costs, the prevalence of money politics, social polarisation, and the high number of regional heads involved in corruption cases. Therefore, this debate is part of the effort to find the best democratic design for Indonesia,” he said.
Nevertheless, with the existence of the Constitutional Court’s ruling, Edo believes that the debate regarding the mechanism of regional elections should now be concluded.
He also stated that the ruling should serve as a momentum to accelerate a comprehensive revision of the Election Law and the Regional Election Law.
Previously, the Constitutional Court declared that the judicial review petition regarding Article 1, point 1 of Law Number 8 of 2015 concerning the Election of Governors, Regents, and Mayors (Regional Election Law) could not be accepted.
This article regulates that regional elections are the implementation of people’s sovereignty in provinces and regencies/cities to elect governors and deputy governors, regents and deputy regents, as well as mayors and deputy mayors directly and democratically.
In their petition, four students named Vendy Setiawan, Lala Komalawati, Susi Lestari, and Afifah Nabila Putri questioned the phrase “directly” in the said article.
In its considerations, the Court found no actual or potential loss of constitutional rights as alleged by the petitioners.
According to the Court, the petitioners’ concerns regarding the possibility of future changes in legal policy, political discourse, and academic anxiety are not a direct consequence of the enforcement of Article 1, point 1 of the Regional Election Law.
This is because, according to the Court, to date, regional elections are still conducted directly by the people.
“The mechanism for regional elections to date is carried out directly by the people, guided by the general principles of elections that apply, while still recognising and respecting local government units that are special or extraordinary,” the Court’s consideration stated.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legislator-constitutional-court-ruling-on-regional-elections-a-momentum-to-build-democratic-design-1782888884)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5630173/legislator-putusan-mk-soal-pilkada-momentum-bangun-desain-demokrasi), translated from Indonesian