Legislator: Constitutional Court ruling on capital city must serve as guiding principle
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Member of the House of Representatives Commission II Indrajaya stated that the Constitutional Court’s (MK) ruling that the national capital remains in Jakarta until a presidential decision on its relocation to the Nusantara Capital (IKN) must serve as the guiding principle in national policy. “The Constitutional Court’s ruling must be the final guiding principle to ensure all national strategic policies proceed based on legal certainty, not merely political will,” Indrajaya said in a statement received in Jakarta on Thursday. According to him, the ruling further strengthens the rule-of-law principle mandated by Article 1 paragraph (3) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia (UUD NRI) that Indonesia is a state based on law. “This is an affirmation that every stage of the capital relocation must have clear constitutional legitimacy,” said the legislator in the field of domestic governance and regional autonomy. Regarding the issuance of a presidential decision on the national capital relocation, Indrajaya emphasised that it is the full authority of President Prabowo Subianto in accordance with the legislative mandate. He stated that the head of state has strategic, administrative, and constitutional considerations before issuing a decision related to relocating the capital from Jakarta to IKN. “If the presidential decision has not been issued to date, it means there are still several important matters that must be prepared thoroughly because relocating the national capital is not a simple matter,” he said. The relocation of the national capital is not merely an issue of physical development and infrastructure, but also concerns constitutional legitimacy, governmental effectiveness, readiness of state apparatus, budget efficiency, and continuity of public services. For him, the capital relocation is a major national agenda that must be prepared thoroughly and comprehensively. “It is not enough to just build buildings and facilities, but also to ensure all aspects of governance are ready to be implemented effectively,” Indrajaya said. The Constitutional Court on Tuesday (12/5) decided to reject a material judicial review application of Law No. 3 of 2022 on the National Capital filed by a doctor named Zulkifli. Zulkifli, a Jakarta resident, challenged the constitutionality of Article 39 paragraph (1) of the National Capital Law because he felt it did not provide legal certainty regarding the provision’s applicability. The article in question reads, “The position, function, and role of the national capital remain in the Special Capital Region of Jakarta Province until the date of the determination of the national capital relocation from the Special Capital Region of Jakarta Province to the Nusantara Capital by presidential decision.” According to him, Article 39 paragraph (1) creates uncertainty regarding the status of the national capital in the national legal system. He argued that, on one hand, Jakarta is no longer designated as the national capital in Law No. 21 of 2023 on the Special Region of Jakarta. On the other hand, the relocation of the national capital to Nusantara has not yet taken effect because the constitutive requirements set by the National Capital Law have not been fulfilled. Therefore, in his application, Zulkifli asked the Constitutional Court to interpret the article to mean that before the presidential decision on the national capital relocation is issued, Jakarta remains the capital of the Republic of Indonesia. However, the Constitutional Court rejected the application. In its legal considerations, the Constitutional Court stated that without the interpretation requested by the applicant, Article 39 paragraph (1) of the National Capital Law has indeed regulated that the position, function, and role of the national capital remain in Jakarta until the presidential decision on relocation to IKN is determined. “In the context of the current application, the applicability of the national capital relocation to the Nusantara Capital depends on the determination and implementation of the aforementioned presidential decision,” as per the Court’s considerations. Therefore, the Constitutional Court concluded that the applicant’s argument that the norm of Article 39 paragraph (1) of the National Capital Law contradicts the constitution is not legally justified.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legislator-constitutional-court-ruling-on-capital-city-must-serve-as-guiding-principle-1778781525)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5567912/legislator-putusan-mk-soal-ibu-kota-negara-harus-jadi-pegangan), translated from Indonesian