Legalising Illegal Cigarettes Erodes Revenue, Triggers Economic Instability
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia - The government’s plan to provide a pathway for illegal cigarette producers to enter the legal clove cigarette industry, in an attempt to reclaim lost excise revenue from the black market, has met with both support and opposition. Meanwhile, legitimate cigarette factories, which have consistently operated within the law, find themselves at a critical low point.
Through the Ministry of Finance, the government is currently preparing a new cigarette ‘layer’ to accommodate illegal cigarettes. Eventually, these illegal producers will be forced into the legal industry under this new regulatory tier.
“We will create a single layer for those illegal cigarettes so they can enter the legal business. I will meet with the House of Representatives (DPR) after the recess; once this is in effect, no illegal cigarette companies will be left unchecked. If they are caught, they will be shut down,” stated Finance Minister Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa during the April APBN KITA release, as reported on Tuesday (12/5/2026).
Piter Abdullah, Policy and Program Director at the Prasasti Center for Policy Studies, believes this policy could have a negative impact on companies currently operating legally, risking the erosion of state revenue. “The total contribution of the tobacco industry was 300 trillion rupiah in 2025. If this market is eroded and taken over by the legalised illegal cigarettes, it could take 50% of the market, reducing that 300 trillion to 150 trillion,” Piter told CNBC Indonesia during the Closing Bell programme.
He described the industry’s current situation as ‘falling from the frying pan into the fire.’ Having not yet recovered from the economic impact of COVID-19 over the past six years, and facing uncertain geopolitical conditions, the industry is now under pressure from new regulations. “The industry is collapsing. The figures tell the story; our cigarette production numbers are declining,” he said.
According to him, this risk arises from the significant price difference between legal and illegal cigarettes. Currently, illegal cigarettes are growing rapidly because they do not bear the excise burden, which can account for 50-80% of the selling price. With much lower prices, illegal cigarettes have captured approximately 16.5% of the market share. Instead of increasing state revenue, this situation risks eroding the revenue base from products that have historically contributed higher excise.
Amidst the industry’s incomplete recovery, the pressure is intensifying. Data from the Directorate General of Customs and Excise shows that national cigarette production in 2025 reached 307.8 billion sticks, a decrease of about 27 billion sticks compared to 2021. This decline reflects ongoing demand pressure and shifts in market structure.
Piter believes that imprecise policies could accelerate industrial decline. “I am worried the industry will collapse. If the industry collapses, state revenue will fall, and I am more concerned about the 6 million people employed there,” said Piter.
The tobacco industry has broad links to the national economy, involving approximately 6 million workers, ranging from farmers and factory workers to small-scale distributors. In this context, shocks to the industry affect not only businesses but also have the potential to trigger wider socio-economic pressure.
Piter emphasised that the issue of illegal cigarettes should not be solved solely through excise structure adjustments, but through strengthened law enforcement. He warned that overly lenient policies could create injustice for businesses that comply with regulations and pay their full excise.
“I am worried that the policy of legalising illegal cigarettes by creating a new layer—providing an excise rate that is vastly different between, for example, SKM Group 1 and this lower layer—will be highly inequitable,” Piter said during the Manufacture Check programme on CNBC Indonesia.
Furthermore, he assessed that the potential for price distortion caused by the new layer could drastically alter the competitive landscape. If not anticipated, this condition could not only erode state revenue but also weaken the overall industrial structure.
“Therefore, it must be carefully weighed: what are the actual benefits versus the harms. From your perspective, how can we ensure this disparity is not too extreme and that this injustice becomes fairness?” Piter asked.
Consequently, caution and balance in formulating policy are key. Without careful calculation, the intended move to bring order risks creating new pressures on state revenue and national economic stability.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legalising-illegal-cigarettes-erodes-revenue-triggers-economic-instability-1780855230)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260603104801-4-739673/legalisasi-rokok-ilegal-gerus-penerimaan-picu-ketidakstabilan-ekonomi), translated from Indonesian