Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Legal Reform Still Far from Complete

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Legal Reform Still Far from Complete
Image: Media Indonesia

More than eight decades since the nation gained independence, Indonesia’s legal development still feels incomplete in delivering full justice to the people. Even post-reform efforts at legal reform appear to be stagnating, despite many fundamental changes in legislative renewal.

The state has produced a great many regulations and carried out various institutional changes, but the end result has not yet provided ideal conditions for society. Coordinating Minister for Law, Human Rights, Immigration and Corrections Yusril Ihza Mahendra highlighted the aspect of developing law enforcement personnel, which he said remains stagnant.

Yusril discussed three other aspects of legal development: the development of legal norms, the development of legal facilities and infrastructure, and the development of legal culture. The following is an excerpt from his interview with Media Indonesia journalists Ahmad Punto and Akhmad Mustain.

How do you view the current legal reform efforts?

As Indonesia approaches 81 years of independence, if we look at it simply, legal development encompasses several aspects. First is the development of legal norms, second is the development of law enforcement apparatus, third is the development of legal facilities and infrastructure, and fourth is building a legal culture, both among law enforcement officers and among the people of this country.

If we look at it, during this reform era, our efforts to build national law have actually been extraordinary. There have been very fundamental legal changes, starting from constitutional amendments to changes in the structure of our state administration, and that process has involved an enormous number of changes to legal norms.

We have also created new institutions. At the judicial level there is the Constitutional Court, there are corruption courts, and there are other special courts.

Then we transferred the authority of the then Minister of Justice to handle the entire judiciary to the Supreme Court, and we created the Corruption Eradication Commission and so on, which made the corruption law much tougher. From a normative perspective, I think we have made a great many changes.

Has law enforcement reform progressed?

If we look at it from the perspective of developing law enforcement apparatus, we can say we have not achieved any progress at all. We have formed institutions. For example, in handling corruption, the police have authority, prosecutors have authority, the KPK has authority. We have also given authority to inspectorates general, to the Finance and Development Supervisory Agency, and the Audit Board to conduct supervision and auditing, and so on.

But despite creating so many institutions and replacing so many law enforcement personnel, our law has not improved; it has only deteriorated further.

Now we see bad examples from law enforcement officers themselves, whether committed by police personnel, prosecutors, or the KPK—I do not know because not much has been heard. The same applies to officials given supervisory authority. If the situation is like this, with bad examples from top to bottom, how can we expect the people to obey the law?

For example, the Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes specifically handles corruption. But there are still many cases of bribery, gratification, extortion, and so on. And it spreads like an octopus down to the lowest levels. I think it will take a generation to change this. Because we build structures and replace personnel, but without strong ethical awareness and high morality in this nation, the law we build will be in vain.

Have the recommendations of the Police Reform Acceleration Commission been accommodated in the revision of the Police Law?

Our task in the Police Reform Acceleration Commission was actually to formulate what the face of the National Police should be now and in the future. But the initiative to revise the Police Law came from the DPR. So it seems disconnected between what the Commission submitted to the President and the draft proposed by the DPR.

The main points remain the same, for example that the Police are under the President—that is still the same. What was not accommodated, among other things, was the strengthening of the National Police Commission. That does not appear at all. So I cannot say much because I was not involved in discussing the bill.

The government was represented by the Minister of Law, but the one active on the ground was Deputy Minister of Law Eddy Hiariej. And when I communicated with him, it was already the final day, when it was about to be passed into law. So I think there are many things we need to improve.

Another point that was emphasised concerns the placement of active police officers in positions outside the Police. There was also a recommendation submitted by the Police Reform Acceleration Committee. And that recommendation was included in the Law, which will then be regulated in a Government Regulation.

From a technology perspective, is Indonesia’s law enforcement adequate?

Our tools for detecting and preventing crime are also far behind. Especially as we enter cybercrime. Especially now with artificial intelligence, people can easily manipulate things, personal data is erased, proxy propaganda runs, I could suddenly give a speech with my voice, but the content is not from me, and in the end there is a political scapegoat—that can happen now. So these are things that we feel are imperfect.

Regarding legal facilities and infrastructure, we continue to lag behind. For example, if we look at correctional institutions or detention centres as one example, we see that law enforcement facilities and infrastructure are insufficient to address the problem. For instance, now there are changes with the Criminal Code and Criminal Procedure Code, including community service and community service sentences to reduce overcapacity, but the facilities and infrastructure do not yet exist, and prisons are overcrowded everywhere.

What about the aspect of developing legal culture?

The development of legal culture in society is also not progressing at all. When people are taught about law—this is allowed, this is not, this is right, this is wrong—it has no effect. Obedience to the law is not because of fear of the police or fear of anything else. That awareness must emerge from a person’s own heart.

Look at the Japanese as an example. Their adherence to ethics is very high. And that high adherence to ethics drives them to obey the law. It is not that Japanese people do not steal because they are afraid of the police. No. They simply know. They know that this is not allowed. If I do that, it goes against my conscience. Perhaps it is ethics, personal awareness.

Law grows as an awareness, obeyed as a necessity. And if we violate the law, there is a feeling that says, ‘this is not allowed, I do not want to do that.’ When it reaches that level, legal culture has grown. If it has not reached that level, legal culture has not yet grown. Where do we cultivate legal culture? From household education, school education, and community education.

Does the low legal culture have an impact on anti-corruption culture?

In the field of corruption, what law could be tougher? There are articles on gratification, bribery, eradication, and so on. The punishment ranges from life imprisonment to the death penalty, already present in corruption legislation. In terms of institutions, there is the KPK, the police, corruption courts, and the Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes. What more could be tougher? Yet the reality is that corruption is becoming increasingly rampant.

It is not only ordinary people who commit corruption. Those committing corruption are precisely law enforcement officers—prosecutors and police are involved. Judges themselves are involved in accepting bribes. Where is this country headed if there are no sufficiently fundamental improvements to what we face?

How is the government responding to this rampant corruption?

Indeed, the current situation cannot be left as it is. Firm steps must be taken. I think President Prabowo has taken a firm step—several officials have been replaced because they were involved in corruption cases. Therefore, the new personnel selected must be the right ones, and then the system must be improved. The system we build must be able to prevent corruption. And we must be consistent about that.

What kind of system improvements?

Start with the political recruitment system. Take the regional elections now, for example. The President has an idea: regional elections should be handed over to the Regional People’s Representative Council only, no longer directly by the people. But it was opposed. The Constitutional Court actually decided to keep direct elections. We are anti-corruption, but on the other hand we are opening wide opportunities for corruption itself.

Do you know how much a regent’s salary is? A mayor’s salary? How much is it? Five to six million or ten million? How much is the operational budget, allowances, and so on? Only around ten million. But the capital needed to campaign to become a regent or mayor can reach Rp30 billion. Where will they recover that Rp30 billion? There is no choice except to open projects involving collusion with businesspeople.

I said, just give it to the DPRD. A DPRD has at most 30 members, sometimes only 20. It is easier to monitor whether those 20 people are bribed than to bribe an entire regency. How can we monitor bribery across an entire regency?

What are your hopes for law enforcement, particularly in efforts to eradicate corruption in this country?

In my view, the most important thing is coordinating law enforcement and coordinating the development of legal norms. The second, which is very important, is coordination in law enforcement itself. We know there are several law enforcement institutions—police, prosecutors, civil servant investigators, and various other institutions.

Most importantly, prosecutors and police must be coordinated so that there is no overlap between law enforcement that falls under police authority but also falls under prosecutorial authority.

For example, money laundering—prosecutors and police can work together, so that there is synchronisation and no overlap. And I am confident that the Coordinating Minister for Political and Security Affairs will handle this matter.

I and the Coordinating Minister for Political and Security Affairs can work together to coordinate this matter as far as law enforcement is concerned. As I did recently, I went to the regions, checked the field, visited regional police headquarters, and held dialogues with regional police after the August 2025 demonstrations, in the context of law enforcement efforts and ensuring no human rights violations occur.

More from 14 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-reform-still-far-from-complete-1786661481)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/921047/reformasi-hukum-masih-jauh-dari-tuntas), translated from Indonesian
Print