Legal Practitioner Says Handling of Former West Java DPRD Chief's Case Potentially Breaches Principles of Justice
The case involving Irfan Soeryanagara is increasingly drawing the attention of legal practitioners. Several irregularities emerging in the handling of the case are assessed as not only leaving significant questions but also potentially undermining the fundamental principles of a state based on the rule of law.
The former Chairman of the West Java DPRD for the 2009-2014 period was returned to detention by the National Police Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim Polri) on Tuesday (9/6), despite having recently been released after serving a three-year prison sentence related to an embezzlement case under Judicial Review Decision No. 97/2024. The senior Democratic Party politician has been detained again over allegations of embezzling 13 land certificates and Money Laundering (TPPU).
Legal practitioner Ali Suage firmly assessed that there are strong indications of error in law, abuse of power, and even criminalisation of a dispute that is more appropriately resolved through civil law mechanisms. According to Ali, if the facts presented by Irfan’s legal counsel are true, then the matter is no longer merely a question of evidence in court, but touches upon more fundamental aspects, namely legal certainty, the protection of human rights, and the professionalism of law enforcement agencies.
“This case needs to be examined seriously. Criminal law must not be used to force the resolution of a dispute whose substance remains within the realm of civil law. If that happens, what emerges is not law enforcement, but criminalisation,” Ali emphasised.
The first point of scrutiny is directed at the alleged violation of the ‘ne bis in odem’ principle, a legal principle that prohibits a person from being tried twice for the same offence after a final and binding decision has been made. Ali explained that, based on circulating information, the object of the case—comprising 13 land certificates—the parties involved, and the disputed loss value are said to be identical to a previous case that had reached final legal standing (inkracht).
“If the object, the legal subjects, and the legal events are indeed the same, then the question is simple: why is a case that has been legally concluded being processed again with almost the same construction? This is where the principle of ne bis in idem becomes relevant to be tested,” he said.
LEGALITY OF EVIDENCE
Furthermore, he assessed that the issue of the legality of evidence also contains unanswered questions. In criminal procedure law, seizure is an essential requirement for an item to be used as valid evidence in court. However, if it is true that the certificates in question were never seized by investigators as regulated by the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP), this could potentially create serious issues regarding the validity of the evidence.
“How can an item be made the object of a criminal case while the status of its seizure is being questioned? This is not merely a technical issue, but concerns the legality of the legal process itself,” he stated.
What is even more concerning, Ali continued, is the construction of the alleged embezzlement offence used in this case. In criminal law, the primary element of embezzlement is the possession of someone else’s property with the intent to possess it unlawfully. Meanwhile, based on developing information, the certificates in question are still registered under the names of Irfan Soeryanagara and his wife.
“A very fundamental legal question arises here. How can someone be alleged to have embezzled goods that, administratively and juridically, are still recorded under their own name? The element of ‘property belonging to another’ must be proven first before discussing embezzlement,” said Ali. He added that if there is no evidence of an unlawful transfer of rights, then the essential elements of the criminal offence may not be met.
MONEY LAUNDERING ISSUES
Not stopping there, Ali also highlighted the re-emergence of Money Laundering (TPPU) allegations in a case where previous rulings had declared them unproven. According to him, if a Judicial Review decision provides different considerations regarding the same substance, such a condition could potentially create legal uncertainty.
“The law must provide certainty, not confusion. If in one decision TPPU is declared unproven, but then appears again in another case construction as if it were still a basis, the public has the right to question the consistency of law enforcement,” he said.
Ali also questioned the reasons for Irfan’s detention, which has lasted more than 101 days. He argued that detention should not be carried out simply because someone holds the status of suspect or defendant. Law enforcement agencies are obliged to prove the existence of objective and subjective reasons as regulated by the KUHAP.
“Is there a risk of flight? Is there an attempt to destroy evidence? Is there a potential to repeat the offence? All of this must be tested. Detention must not turn into a form of punishment before there is a final and binding court decision,” he said.
ARREST PROCESS
The final scrutiny was directed at the arrest process, which was reportedly carried out simultaneously with the first summons, even though there were subsequent summons scheduled. For Ali, this situation raises serious questions regarding respect for the principle of due process of law. “When legal procedures are not carried out carefully, the justice that is the primary goal of the law can be threatened. Therefore, the validity of the arrest and detention is highly worthy of being tested through the pretrial mechanism,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-practitioner-says-handling-of-former-west-java-dprd-chiefs-case-potentially-breaches-principles-of-1781016812)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/nusantara/898699/praktisi-hukum-sebut-penanganan-kasus-mantan-ketua-dprd-jawa-barat-berpotensi-melanggar-prinsip-keadilan), translated from Indonesian