Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Legal Expert: Supreme Court Ruling on Gibran’s Degree Equivalency Does Not Automatically Remove Him as Vice-President

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Legal Expert: Supreme Court Ruling on Gibran’s Degree Equivalency Does Not Automatically Remove Him as Vice-President
Image: Republika

JAKARTA — The Supreme Court’s (MA) decision granting a lawsuit concerning the educational equivalency certificate of Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka does not automatically invalidate his position as Vice-President. The validity of an educational administrative document and the removal of a state official have different legal bases and procedures.

Legal expert Deny Hariyatna, S.H., M.H., explained that the Supreme Court ruling concerns an administrative court (TUN) dispute. The matter at issue is the validity of an educational equivalency certificate issued by a government administrative official.

Deny said the legal consequences of the ruling must be considered in light of the scope of the case examined by the court. Annulment of an administrative decision cannot immediately be interpreted as cancelling someone’s status in a constitutional office.

“An Administrative Court ruling is directed at an administrative official; the error must be viewed as an administrative error,” Deny said in a written statement.

He made the remarks following the Supreme Court’s cassation ruling No. 742 K/TUN/2026 on Friday (30 October 2026). In the case, the court granted a cassation appeal filed by Subhan Palal against the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education over Gibran’s certificate of equivalency for secondary-school education.

The panel of judges overturned the previous court ruling and decided the case itself, granting the claimant’s lawsuit in full. The decision has revived debate about Gibran’s educational documents when he ran for Vice-President in the 2024 election.

Deny said there was a fundamental difference between assessing the validity of an administrative document and determining whether the requirements for the office of Vice-President had been met.

“There has been no legal or judicial finding stating that the Vice-President as an individual no longer meets the requirements,” he said.

In his view, an administrative court ruling must be implemented according to its operative provisions and legal scope. However, those administrative consequences do not in themselves determine whether the Vice-President’s term should continue.

Deny also pointed to provisions on educational documents for presidential and vice-presidential candidates in General Elections Commission Regulation (PKPU) No. 19 of 2023.

Article 18, paragraph 3 of the regulation provides an exception to submitting proof of secondary-school graduation for candidates who do not have such proof from a foreign secondary school abroad and who already hold proof of university graduation.

According to Deny, this provision should be considered when discussing the completeness of candidacy paperwork. However, the document-submission exception does not remove each candidate’s obligation to meet the educational requirements set out in law.

Another issue concerns the procedure for removing the President or Vice-President, which is specifically set out in the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.

More from 4 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-expert-supreme-court-ruling-on-gibrans-degree-equivalency-does-not-automatically-remove-him-as-vice-1793807461)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tnzcwq451/pakar-hukum-putusan-ma-soal-penyetaraan-ijazah-gibran-tak-otomatis-gugurkan-jabatan-wapres), translated from Indonesian
Print