Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Legal Expert Says Clear Benchmarks Are Needed for Planned Regulation of Cigarette Additives

| Source: VIVA.co.id Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
Legal Expert Says Clear Benchmarks Are Needed for Planned Regulation of Cigarette Additives
Image: VIVA.co.id

Jakarta — Legal expert and lecturer at the Litigasi College of Law, Michael Hadylaya, has stressed that the planned regulation of additives and flavourings in cigarettes through a Minister of Health Decree (KMK) must have clear benchmarks. He made the remarks in Jakarta while commenting on the drafting of implementing rules for Government Regulation No. 28 of 2024 on the implementation of the Health Law.

Hadylaya questioned the proposed criterion that products be “not harmful to health”, which would place the burden on manufacturers. He said requiring producers to prove the absence of every risk under all circumstances would be difficult to achieve in practice.

“Requiring producers to prove the absence of all risks in every situation would create an obligation that is practically impossible to meet. The state needs to establish standards with clear, workable indicators, so businesses understand their obligations and the public can assess whether protections are adequate,” Hadylaya said in a written statement on Saturday (31 October 2026).

He said restrictions on additives should adhere to the principle of proportionality and be supported by concrete evidence of causation. That evidence, he added, must provide detailed consideration of the substance’s properties, its concentration and the effects of its use.

“The general dangers of smoking are not enough to explain the need to prohibit every additive,” he said, describing the need for objective assessment criteria.

Hadylaya also urged the government to learn from the World Trade Organisation (WTO) dispute between Indonesia and the United States over clove cigarettes. Any regulation, he said, must be non-discriminatory and based on scientific evidence that can be transparently justified.

“The lesson we can take is the importance of providing a defensible explanation. The state has room to regulate product characteristics, but it must exercise that authority consistently, on the basis of relevant evidence and in proportion to the objective being pursued,” Hadylaya said.

The Ministry of Health is currently finalising implementing rules concerning the prohibition of additives in tobacco products and electronic cigarettes, with the aim of avoiding disruption to industrial production.

Tags: berita

More from 31 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-expert-says-clear-benchmarks-are-needed-for-planned-regulation-of-cigarette-additives-1793530270)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1940027-soroti-rencana-kmk-bahan-tambahan-rokok-ahli-hukum-butuh-indikator-tolok-ukur-yang-jelas), translated from Indonesian
Print