Legal Expert on Asset Forfeiture Bill: 'Asset Recovery' a More Appropriate Term
Guru Besar Hukum Universitas Islam Sultan Agung (Unissula) Semarang, Yehezkiel Minggus Tiranda, has proposed that the terminology in the Asset Forfeiture Bill be reviewed.
Yehezkiel said the use of the term ‘asset recovery’ should be considered because it is seen as better reflecting the restorative objective compared to the term ‘asset forfeiture’.
“If I refer to the RDPU proposal yesterday, why not asset recovery? Why must it be asset forfeiture? I prefer that terminology (asset recovery),” Yehezkiel said in his statement on Thursday (6/8).
According to him, the use of the term asset forfeiture is indeed more assertive from a law enforcement perspective. However, the term is also considered to have the potential to create a repressive impression in the public eye.
“From the perspective of public impression, the term forfeiture is repressive. But if we use the term recovery, it is indeed more humane,” he said.
From a legal perspective, the Supreme Court justice candidate explained that the term asset forfeiture focuses more on the perpetrator. Meanwhile, the term asset recovery places more emphasis on the interests of the victim, including the state as the aggrieved party.
Yehezkiel also touched on the aspect of international cooperation. According to him, the terminology of asset recovery used in the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) is closer to the concept of asset recovery than asset forfeiture.
“If we use the term forfeiture, this is indeed the American model. But the UNCAC term is asset recovery. We just need to choose which one makes international cooperation easier,” he said.
Beyond the nomenclature issue, Yehezkiel assessed that the most crucial aspect in the drafting of the bill actually lies in the transitional provisions and closing provisions.
This is because, he said, almost 80 percent of new laws and amendments to laws become objects of dispute at the Constitutional Court due to issues with transitional provisions. Therefore, the regulation in that section needs to be carefully designed so that the transition of rule implementation runs more smoothly.
“Everything can be regulated smoothly in the transitional provisions and closing provisions,” he said.
Furthermore, Yehezkiel also understood that the deliberation of the Asset Forfeiture Bill requires caution because it involves many interests.
“I understand the atmosphere in the DPR representing those who are afraid and those who are brave. This is a psychological condition so we must truly position ourselves appropriately and we must be careful in bringing this bill forward,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-expert-on-asset-forfeiture-bill-asset-recovery-a-more-appropriate-term-1786031545)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260806203332-12-1389505/pakar-hukum-soal-ruu-perampasan-aset-lebih-tepat-istilah-pemulihan), translated from Indonesian