Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Legal Expert: Asset Recovery More Appropriate Than Asset Forfeiture

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Legal Expert: Asset Recovery More Appropriate Than Asset Forfeiture
Image: Media Indonesia

The use of the term ‘asset forfeiture’ in the Draft Law on Asset Forfeiture needs to be evaluated. Professor of Law at Sultan Agung Islamic University (Unissula) Semarang, Yehezkiel Minggus Tiranda, has proposed that the terminology be changed to ‘asset recovery’ as it is considered to better reflect a restorative spirit rather than mere punishment.

According to Yehezkiel, the term asset recovery is more accurately targeted in describing the legal objectives to be achieved. “If I refer to the previous Limited Hearing proposal, why not asset recovery? Why must it be asset forfeiture? I prefer that terminology (asset recovery),” he said in a statement on Thursday.

He explained that although the term forfeiture demonstrates firm law enforcement, it risks creating a repressive impression in the public eye. Conversely, the term recovery is considered more humane and oriented towards the interests of victims, including the state which has suffered losses. “From a public perception standpoint, the term forfeiture is repressive. But if we use the term recovery, it is indeed more humane,” said the former Head of the Change Management Team for the Core Tax Administration System Renewal at the Directorate General of Taxes.

From an international legal perspective, Yehezkiel noted that the term asset recovery used in the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) has a closer equivalent to the concept of pemulihan aset. He argued that choosing terminology aligned with international conventions would facilitate cooperation between countries. “If we use the term forfeiture, this is the American model. But the UNCAC term is asset recovery. We just need to choose which one makes international cooperation easier,” he added.

Beyond the issue of naming, the candidate for Supreme Court Justice emphasised that the most crucial part of drafting this bill lies in the transitional and closing provisions. He noted that almost 80 per cent of new laws become the object of disputes in the Constitutional Court due to problems with regulatory transitions. “All the substance can be whatever it is, but we can be moderate in the transitional and closing rules. We can arrange everything smoothly there so that the implementation transition runs better,” he explained.

Yehezkiel also provided a critical note on Article 5 paragraph (2) letter a of the draft bill, which regulates assets disproportionate to income. He assessed that this norm is very complex and requires detailed explanation to avoid legal uncertainty. He cited the example of valuing digital assets such as social media accounts that could be worth billions of Rupiah, or the difference between the value of a crime and the total assets owned by an individual. “Many things need to be clarified so as not to create legal uncertainty,” he stated.

Concluding his remarks, Yehezkiel reminded that the deliberation of this bill requires a high degree of caution because it concerns the psychological condition and various interests within the legislature. “I understand the atmosphere in the DPR, representing those who are fearful and those who are brave. We must be careful in advancing this bill,” he concluded.

More from 6 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-expert-asset-recovery-more-appropriate-than-asset-forfeiture-1785999065)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/918921/pakar-hukum-pemulihan-aset-lebih-tepat-dibanding-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian
Print