Legal Counsel Claims Transmigration Land Case in Kukar Falls Under Civil Jurisdiction
The legal team of Budiono Tanbun (BT) has urged the panel of judges at the Samarinda District Court to acquit their client and dismiss the charges brought by the public prosecutor relating to alleged corruption over transmigration land in Kutai Kartanegara. The defence considers the case, which allegedly cost the state Rp696.9 billion, to have expired under the statute of limitations and to be purely a civil dispute.
The request was submitted in a defence note, or exception, read out by the defendant’s counsel, Andi Simangunsong, at the first hearing held at the Samarinda District Court in East Kalimantan on Tuesday (28/7).
The defence argued that the case has expired under prevailing legal provisions, and maintains that the core of the dispute raised by the public prosecutor would be more appropriately resolved through civil law mechanisms.
The request was based on the argument that the case has passed the statute of limitations and that its substance falls within the realm of civil law.
In reading the exception, Andi Simangunsong explained that the alleged criminal acts specifically attributed to his client occurred between January and December 2007.
Under the old Criminal Code, which applies to this case, the prosecution period for such an offence is 18 years, meaning the deadline formally expired in December 2025. This is because the alleged acts took place before the new Criminal Code came into force. Accordingly, the prosecution’s authority to pursue the case should be declared void.
“The public prosecutor only filed the charges in July 2026, so it is already too late, because the statute of limitations expired at the end of December 2025. Under the law, the court should therefore declare the prosecution against Mr Budiono void, the charges must be declared inadmissible, and Mr Budiono must be immediately released,” he said.
Furthermore, he said, the case is purely a dispute over management rights and mining permits, in which the company had already acquired the land from residents holding certificates of ownership.
“If it is considered a case of mistaken targeting, then it falls within the civil domain, not a corruption offence,” said Andi.
The defence team therefore urged the panel of judges to declare the charges inadmissible and to immediately release the defendant BT.
Meanwhile, public prosecutor Riko Kriswantoro set out that the defendant BT, as director of PT KRA and PT ABE, allegedly conducted coal mining operations partly within the Separi Land Management (HPL) area in Kutai Kartanegara Regency. The activity was allegedly carried out without a permit from the Directorate General of Transmigration.
The prosecutor stated that the alleged illegal mining also involved a witness with the initials HM, who served as Head of the Kutai Kartanegara Mining and Energy Office from 2005 to 2008 and was assessed as having failed to carry out any supervisory or control measures.
The activity was claimed to have produced 1,896,876 tonnes of coal. According to the audit report by the East Kalimantan Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP) dated 15 June 2026, the alleged act enriched the corporations and cost the state Rp696.9 billion.
After hearing the charges read by the prosecution and the exception from the defence, the presiding judge of the Samarinda District Court, Jemmy Tanjung Utama, accompanied by member judge Nur Salamah, decided to adjourn the proceedings. The panel closed the hearing and will resume next week.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-counsel-claims-transmigration-land-case-in-kukar-falls-under-civil-jurisdiction-1785325867)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/916079/kuasa-hukum-sebut-kasus-lahan-transmigrasi-di-kukar-dinilai-masuk-ranah-perdata), translated from Indonesian