Legal counsel calls Febrie pretrial ruling a procedural paradox
Jakarta (ANTARA) - Febrie Adriansyah’s lawyer, Firman Wijaya, has assessed that the South Jakarta District Court’s decision to reject his client’s pretrial motion constitutes a procedural paradox, or something contrary to common assumptions.
“In fact, the pretrial judge acknowledged that, yes, there were procedural irregularities. I can say this is a procedural paradox, which is already evident from the existing evidence. However, it seems that was considered as nothing, and then the experts’ considerations were not taken into account at all,” Firman told reporters after the second pretrial ruling for Febrie Adriansyah at the South Jakarta District Court on Friday.
Firman stated that he respects the judge’s decision, although he questioned the legal considerations which he deemed inconsistent with the ruling. He said the pretrial judge was said to have acknowledged the existence of procedural irregularities or carelessness in the naming of Febrie Adriansyah as a suspect and his detention by the Attorney General’s Office.
However, the judge instead decided to reject his client’s pretrial motion. Firman referred to this condition as a procedural paradox.
“So, we see that on one hand the pretrial judge acknowledges that there were indeed errors, procedural carelessness, but in the end the judge instead issued a different judgement,” Firman said.
Firman said the evidence was also reinforced by the testimony of several experts. He highlighted, among other things, the alleged violation of the Attorney General’s Regulation (Perja), including the issue of the authority of the official who determined the suspect status.
“In fact, the experts also said that the Perja is a requirement that must be followed in a strictly limited manner operationally and functionally, unless there are other matters that cause the Perja to be unable to be implemented,” Firman said.
Moreover, according to him, Febrie’s case has broader issues because the pretrial motion does not only concern the suspect designation, but also various coercive measures.
He said the legal team found dozens of issues based on research into the case documents.
“In fact, our team previously mentioned almost 30 to 40, based on the results of our research into the documents,” Firman revealed.
Firman also questioned the use of an old legal approach in the handling of Febrie Adriansyah’s case, while Indonesia already has a new Criminal Code (KUHP) and Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP) as well as a law on criminal adjustments.
Nevertheless, Firman stressed that the legal team still respects the judge’s decision and will consult further with Febrie Adriansyah regarding the next legal steps.
He also mentioned that there is still room to examine the matter academically, including through an examination to see whether the evidence submitted truly shows serious problems in the handling of Febrie Adriansyah’s case.
As is known, the South Jakarta District Court judge has rejected two pretrial motions by Febrie Adriansyah. Thus, the detention and suspect status of Febrie in the alleged money laundering (TPPU) case are lawful.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/legal-counsel-calls-febrie-pretrial-ruling-a-procedural-paradox-1787928737)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5715955/kuasa-hukum-nilai-putusan-praperadilan-febrie-paradoks-prosedural), translated from Indonesian