Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Learning from Malaysia: Spin-offs Alone Not Enough to Boost Sharia Insurance

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Learning from Malaysia: Spin-offs Alone Not Enough to Boost Sharia Insurance
Image: CNBC Indonesia

When the government and industry players in Indonesia are racing to strengthen the sharia insurance industry through the spin-off policy for sharia business units (UUS), Malaysia’s experience points in the opposite direction.

The success of Malaysia’s sharia insurance industry was not born solely from changes in institutional structure and rising public demand, but from strengthening distribution capacity.

The latest IFG Progress study, titled “From Supply Expansion to Sustainable Growth: Lessons from Malaysia’s Sharia Life Insurance Industry”, shows that the transformation of Malaysia’s sharia life insurance industry took place through systematic stages, namely supply expansion, market penetration, demand activation, and sustainable growth.

Malaysia is one of the benchmarks for sharia life insurance industry development in Southeast Asia. The neighbouring country has managed to increase the market share of sharia life insurance from around 24% in 2020 to nearly 36% in 2025.

This condition shows that the sharia industry is no longer positioned as a niche market, but has become one of the main pillars of Malaysia’s national insurance industry.

The success was not solely caused by increasing public awareness of sharia products. Rather, there was a gradual industry development strategy that was able to create sustainable growth.

These findings are relevant for Indonesia, which is currently entering a new phase of sharia insurance industry development.

One of the most interesting findings in this research is that the growth of Malaysia’s sharia insurance industry in the early phase was not driven by rising demand, but by strengthening the supply side.

In the 2010-2014 period, sharia insurance companies in Malaysia focused more on expanding the number of agents and enlarging distribution networks than on pursuing short-term sales growth. The large investment in marketing networks was made to expand public access to sharia insurance products so that when demand began to grow, the industry already had adequate distribution capacity.

Data shows that the number of agents increased much faster than new business policy growth in the early phase. In other words, Malaysia first built a distribution “motorway” before expecting demand traffic to increase.

This approach differs from the common view that increased literacy or rising public income will automatically increase insurance penetration.

After the distribution foundation was successfully built, the growth pattern of Malaysia’s sharia insurance industry began to change. New business premiums per capita began to grow faster than the growth in the number of agents. This means that the distribution capacity built earlier began to generate real increases in demand. The public not only bought policies in greater numbers, but also increased the value of protection they held.

IFG Progress research also found that demand growth was supported by Malaysia’s rising GDP per capita. Interestingly, premium value growth was still accompanied by product affordability. During 2015-2025, the ratio of premiums to GDP per capita remained below 3%, showing that the increase in participant contributions did not burden public purchasing power.

In other words, industry growth occurred not because products became increasingly expensive, but because more people were able and willing to buy protection.

Contrary to the perception that investment products are the main growth engine, Malaysia’s experience actually shows the dominance of traditional protection products.

In the business in force portfolio, the share of traditional products has continued to increase since around 2017 and has again become the largest contributor compared to investment-linked or unit-linked products. Even in new business, traditional products consistently control around 80%-90% of total premiums.

These findings show that the success of Malaysia’s sharia insurance industry was built on the ability to provide products that are simple, easy to understand, relevant to public needs, and remain affordable.

Malaysia’s experience shows that sharia life insurance industry growth becomes more sustainable when product development is focused on the public’s primary needs, namely protection against everyday risks with affordable premiums and clear benefits.

For Indonesia, this lesson is important amid efforts to expand sharia insurance penetration. A focus on retail protection products is likely to have a greater impact than relying too heavily on investment-oriented products.

Malaysia did not stop at increasing the number of participants. The next stage was ensuring that industry growth also produced economic benefits felt by participants. This is reflected in rising new business, growing business in force, and increasing distribution of surplus to participants as an implementation of the risk-sharing principle.

Throughout 2019-2025, new business premiums grew at a CAGR of 63%, while business in force increased by 53%. At the same time, the ratio of surplus distribution to active policies also continued to increase after the pandemic. This combination strengthened public trust in the industry while increasing participant retention.

IFG Progress research also conducted empirical testing using the LOWESS method and Spearman correlation to determine the factors most influential on new policy growth.

The results were quite interesting. GDP per capita growth turned out not to have a statistically significant relationship with new business policy growth. Conversely, growth in the number of agents had a strong and significant positive correlation with new policy increases, with a Spearman correlation coefficient of 0.675 and a significance level of 1%.

These findings strengthen the argument that in the early stages of industry development, policies focused on strengthening distribution are more effective than relying solely on increasing public purchasing power.

Malaysia’s experience provides several important lessons for Indonesia, which is currently entering a new era of sharia insurance industry following the spin-off of sharia business units.

First, industry reform is not enough if carried out only through changes in institutional structure. Strengthening distribution networks needs to be a priority so that products become easier for the public to access.

Second, increasing sharia financial literacy and inclusion must be carried out after distribution capacity is formed so that it can turn access into real demand.

Third, product development should be oriented towards protection that is simple, relevant, and affordable, especially for the retail segment. Fourth, industry success is not only measured by premium growth, but also by the ability to retain participants through increased business in force, service quality, and benefit distribution that strengthens public trust.

The obligation to spin off sharia business units will indeed give birth to more independent sharia entities, but Malaysia’s experience shows that adding players does not automatically increase market penetration. Success is actually determined by companies’ ability to build distribution capacity, present protection products that suit public needs, and create sustainable value for participants.

In other words, spin-off is the starting point of transformation, not its final goal. For Indonesia’s sharia insurance market share to increase significantly, strengthening the distribution ecosystem, product innovation, sharia financial literacy, and participant retention need to run simultaneously.

More from 7 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/learning-from-malaysia-spin-offs-alone-not-enough-to-boost-sharia-insurance-1786081885)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/research/20260807104010-128-757353/belajar-dari-malaysia-spin-off-saja-tak-cukup-dorong-asuransi-syariah), translated from Indonesian
Print