Lawyer: Yaqut Never Received or Gave Money in Hajj Quota Case
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The legal advisory team for former Minister of Religious Affairs (Menag) Yaqut Cholil Qoumas has denied that their client received or gave money, either directly or through intermediaries, in connection with the alleged hajj quota corruption case.
“If there are certain parties claiming to have received instructions from our client or carried out our client’s instructions regarding this matter, such statements are untrue and must be proven legally, not disseminated as final and proven truths,” said Dodi S. Abdulkadir, one of Yaqut’s legal advisors, in a right of reply received by ANTARA in Jakarta on Monday.
The right of reply concerns ANTARA’s reporting with the titles:
https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5525324/kpk-perantara-aliran-uang-dari-yaqut-ke-pansus-haji-dpr-berinisial-za
https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5525321/kpk-telah-sita-1-juta-dolar-as-yang-disiapkan-untuk-pansus-haji-dpr
Dodi stated that Yaqut was also never balancedly confirmed regarding the existence of the US$1 million, was never shown the flow of the said money, and was never asked to provide an explanation or confrontation regarding the origin of that money.
“He was never asked if he ever received that money and was never asked if he ever gave that money, either personally or through other parties,” Dodi said.
In such circumstances, according to him, reporting that uses affirmative phrasing as if a “giving” by Yaqut had occurred has shaped the perception that their client committed the act.
Consequently, he has been “punished” in the public sphere before any material truth is proven through a court examination process.
“This is a clear form of trial by the press that harms the presumption of innocence principle and our client’s right to a fair legal process,” he said.
Dodi assessed that the narrative in the published news was built almost entirely from statements by law enforcement officials (APH) in a press conference.
“In the article we reviewed, law enforcement officials stated that the money was ‘allegedly prepared by Yaqut’, ‘handed over by Yaqut’, or ‘already received by ZA’,” he said.
Meanwhile, according to him, at the same time, no balanced space was given to Yaqut to provide a response, explanation, or rebuttal.
“Yet one of the special committee members was reported as stating that they were unaware of the matter and claimed to be surprised by the narrative of the intended conditioning effort,” Dodi said.
This shows that the news does not present a complete picture but merely amplifies one-sided claims by law enforcement as if they were material truths.
He explained that in criminal cases, especially those not yet decided by a court ruling with final legal force, the language used in reporting must remain within the framework of allegations.
“However, the published reporting instead uses affirmative and judgemental phrases, such as ‘prepared by Yaqut’, ‘handed over by Yaqut’, or ‘money from Yaqut already in the hands of the intermediary’, thus directing the public to accept it as if the legal facts are settled,” Dodi said.
Furthermore, he revealed that Yaqut had met with officials from the Financial Audit Board (BPK) of Indonesia to express readiness for confrontation and request clarification from parties claiming the existence of fund flows and/or fund giving.
“However, the said parties were never brought forward for clarification or open and objective confrontation,” Dodi said.
His side suspects there may be an effort to cover up actual practices at the operational level of hajj pilgrimage organisation, including possible deviations in the management of the Integrated Hajj Computerisation System (Siskohat) and/or quota filling.
“By diverting the issue as if the problem lies in the quota setting policy or even in bribery allegations against the DPR RI Special Committee,” he revealed.
In fact, according to him, the root problem that emerges is in the quota filling mechanism and its connection to Siskohat.
“Thus, it is very possible that this US$1 million issue was publicised to build an opinion that obscures the real source of the problem, which is suspected to be at the operational level of hajj pilgrimage organisation,” Dodi said.
He conveyed that if there is indeed a flow of funds, serious law enforcement can easily uncover the parties who truly know, collect, control, and use that money and to whom it is directed.
“In this case, the judicial process to test the material truth has not been carried out, but the narrative of punishing our client has already been formed in the public sphere beforehand,” he said.
He stated that if based on the reporting there is money that was only seized or returned after the case became spotlighted, then that is not a reason to immediately attach stigma to Yaqut.
“Rather, it is a reason to seriously dismantle who knew about the money from the beginning, who held it, who ordered it, who received it, and who returned it. Without all that, mentioning our client’s name in the title and content of the news as the source of the money is merely a form of judgement and does not respect the presumption of innocence principle,” Dodi said.
He said the organisation of the 1445 Hijriah/2024 CE hajj pilgrimage has been audited by the BPK of Indonesia, and in the audit results, the BPK even stated there were efficiency funds of approximately Rp600 billion.
Therefore, according to him, it is very unfair if policies or implementations that have been audited and shown efficiency are narrowed into a narrative of bribery and political conditioning, without complete proof and balanced clarification/verification to Yaqut.
“This further shows that the reporting does not
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lawyer-yaqut-never-received-or-gave-money-in-hajj-quota-case-1777279894)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5543795/pengacara-yaqut-tak-pernah-menerima-memberi-uang-di-kasus-kuota-haji), translated from Indonesian