Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Lawyer highlights absence of 'Miranda Rules' in Febrie's pretrial ruling

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Lawyer highlights absence of 'Miranda Rules' in Febrie's pretrial ruling
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Jakarta (ANTARA) - Febrie Adriansyah’s lawyer, Alvon Kurnia, has highlighted the non-application of the Miranda Rules principle in the South Jakarta District Court ruling that rejected his client’s pretrial motion.

Miranda Rules refer to the constitutional rights of a suspect or defendant, including the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel.

“Miranda Rules is a rule that arose because of mistakes made by law enforcement in America. The essence is that if certain words are not spoken, for example ‘you have the rights’, then that becomes grounds for annulment. So, if those words are not uttered, it becomes void. This is interesting because that did not happen in the current ruling,” Alvon said at the South Jakarta District Court on Friday.

He said that pretrial proceedings are an effort to protect suspects’ rights, referring to the Miranda Rules, particularly to ensure that law enforcement officers inform suspects of their rights.

According to Alvon, the principle teaches that if a suspect’s rights are not communicated by law enforcement officers, the legal process can be declared void.

Alvon said that in the court’s considerations, administrative issues were mentioned, but these were deemed insufficient grounds to annul the legal process.

“Because here, it was repeatedly stated that, yes, there were administrative issues, but they were not fundamental problems, and they did not constitute grounds to annul a legal process,” Alvon said.

According to him, procedural errors should not be viewed separately from efforts to obtain substantive justice, because incorrect procedures can affect the entire legal process.

“In fact, a procedural error will affect the process of obtaining substantive justice,” Alvon said.

Alvon also assessed that the judge’s considerations in Febrie’s pretrial ruling showed hesitation. He linked this to the principle of in dubio pro reo, namely the principle that if there is doubt, that doubt should benefit the person who is suspected or accused.

“There is a legal principle in law called in dubio pro reo. The essence is that if there is doubt, it should not be thrown to the main case, but rather it should benefit the person who filed the petition,” Alvon said.

Furthermore, he said the issue relates to the human rights perspective in criminal justice proceedings. Therefore, if there is doubt about the validity of a stage in the legal process, it should be resolved through the pretrial mechanism.

In addition to the Miranda Rules, Alvon also highlighted an alleged contradiction between the considerations in Ruling Number 134 and Ruling Number 135, which he said relate to the examination of prospective suspects.

He said his team would review those considerations again, while still respecting the single judge’s ruling that rejected Febrie Adriansyah’s pretrial motion.

As is known, the South Jakarta District Court judge has rejected two pretrial motions filed by Febrie Adriansyah. Thus, Febrie’s detention and his suspect status in the alleged money laundering case are lawful.

More from 28 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lawyer-highlights-absence-of-miranda-rules-in-febries-pretrial-ruling-1787928759)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5715992/kuasa-hukum-soroti-tak-ada-miranda-rules-dalam-praperadilan-febrie), translated from Indonesian
Print