LaNyalla Proposes Reconstructing DPD RI Membership in Summa Cum Laude Doctoral Dissertation
Jakarta (ANTARA) – DPD RI member AA LaNyalla Mahmud Mattalitti has earned a doctorate with a Summa Cum Laude distinction after defending his dissertation, entitled “Reconstructing Membership of the Republic of Indonesia’s Representative Bodies from Non-Political Party Constituencies”, at Airlangga University (Unair) in Surabaya.
At an open doctoral examination held at Unair’s ASSEC Tower on Wednesday (11 November), LaNyalla examined anomalies and structural flaws in Indonesia’s constitutional system. He proposed reconstructing membership of representative bodies to include non-party candidates, breaking the political parties’ monopoly and addressing the deadlock in articulating public aspirations.
In his academic research, the fifth chair of the DPD RI, serving from 2019 to 2024, analysed Article 22E(3) of the 1945 Constitution, which restricts participation in elections for the House of Representatives (DPR RI) to political parties.
He argued that this provision has contributed to a “recall bottleneck”, in which representatives are more responsive to factional discipline and the threat of replacement between elections (Pergantian Antarwaktu, or PAW) by party elites than to the aspirations of their constituents.
As a solution, LaNyalla proposed a constitutional reform (ius constituendum) to open a route for independent, non-party candidates to become members of the DPR RI.
“This independent route is a democratic safety valve. It breaks the political parties’ monopoly and restores direct accountability to the people,” LaNyalla said during his dissertation presentation.
The independent route would also provide broad opportunities for non-partisan groups, including technocrats, academics and professionals, to serve in the main law-making chamber without having to submit to a particular party ideology.
LaNyalla outlined three potential benefits if individual candidacies were allowed in the DPR RI. First, they would strengthen checks and balances within the legislature.
Second, they could break up oversized coalitions between political parties and the government, which, he said, often produce policies favouring elites and harming the public.
Third, they could minimise conflicts of interest arising from political party sponsors’ influence, helping to ensure greater fairness in regulations covering the environment, health, spatial planning and employment.
He cited South Africa as his main comparative example. In 2020, South Africa’s Constitutional Court ruled that the country’s electoral law was unconstitutional because it prevented citizens from standing independently for election to the National Assembly. The ruling was followed by the passage of an amendment to the Electoral Act in 2023.
Individual candidacies have also long been part of representative systems in developed countries including the United Kingdom, the United States, Australia, Germany and France.
Alongside opening an independent route to the DPR, LaNyalla’s dissertation highlighted the pronounced imbalance between the DPR RI and the DPD RI, describing the arrangement as “soft bicameralism”. His five years leading the DPD RI, he said, had shown him that regional aspirations were often sidelined by centralising policies in the DPR.
He therefore called for the DPD RI to be given equal standing with the DPR RI as a co-legislator in matters of legislation, budgeting and oversight.
To implement the proposals, he recommended comprehensive amendments to Articles 22E(3) and 22D of the 1945 Constitution.
“True sovereignty cannot be represented by an oligarchy; it must be returned to its rightful owners: the people of Indonesia,” LaNyalla said.
LaNyalla has officially received a Doctor of Law and Development degree from Unair’s Postgraduate School.
The open examination was attended by the examining panel, including Professors Ramdhoni, Suparto Wijoyo, Muhammad Nafik Hadi, Dossy Iskandar Prasetyo, Muhammad Hatta Ali, Radian Salam and Mas Rahmah, as well as Dr Wahyu Aditama and Dr Prawita Thalib.
Academic guests who posed questions included Dr Mulyadi of the University of Indonesia’s Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, DPD RI members Professor Dailami Firdaus and Dr Badikenita Br Sitepu, and Deputy Minister of Manpower Dr Afriansyah Noor.
Also attending were MPR RI Deputy Speaker Akbar Supratman, Presidential Advisory Council member Dr Soekarwo, members of the DPR and DPD RI, regional leadership coordination forum officials, community figures, KADIN leaders and sports organisation officials.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/lanyalla-proposes-reconstructing-dpd-ri-membership-in-summa-cum-laude-doctoral-dissertation-1794416042)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5847915/lanyalla-rekonstruksi-keanggotaan-dpd-ri-raih-doktor-summa-cumlaude), translated from Indonesian