Labour Protections Do Not Deter Investment, Observer Says
Strengthening workers’ rights does not automatically cause investors to leave Indonesia. Legal certainty, infrastructure, productivity and workforce quality are among the important factors considered when deciding where to invest. Labour observer Arif Novianto rejected the claim that greater protection for workers would automatically reduce investment interest.
He made the remarks when contacted by Kompas.com on Saturday (14 November 2026), as reported by Money. Arif said labour policy needed to be viewed in a broader context. The relationship between stronger workers’ rights and investor decisions could not be assessed solely by looking at labour costs.
“In my view, this argument needs to be considered more proportionately. We cannot simply say that every increase in worker protection will make investors flee,” Arif said.
Low wages are not the only factor in investment
Companies consider a range of conditions that support business operations when choosing where to invest. These include legal certainty, infrastructure, workforce capabilities, economic stability, market access, productivity and consistency in government policy. Arif acknowledged that labour costs are part of investors’ calculations. However, he said relying on low wages as the main attraction was not a sound long-term development strategy.
“I do not deny that labour costs are one consideration for investors. But making low wages the main investment advantage is not a healthy development strategy in the long term,” Arif added. Dependence on low labour costs could leave Indonesia trapped in a low-wage development model.
Under this model, capital inflows do not necessarily lead to better-quality jobs. Employment opportunities may increase, but productivity could struggle to improve if workers’ skills and welfare are neglected. This shows that investment levels should be considered alongside the quality of the jobs created. Investment based solely on low-cost labour may not deliver optimal benefits for economic development or workers’ lives.
Government should steer investment towards productive activities
Arif called for a shift in investment policy so that it does not focus solely on reducing labour costs. In his view, the business climate should support higher productivity, innovation and the creation of decent jobs.
“In my view, we need to change the direction of investment policy. The question is not simply how to make labour as cheap as possible to attract investors, but how to build an investment climate that is productive, innovative and provides decent work,” Arif said. The government should therefore consider the type of investment it wants to promote.
The choice is not limited to capital that relies on low wages and worker flexibility; it also includes investment that brings advances in technology and production capacity. Arif said technology transfer, better-quality jobs, productivity and public welfare should all inform decisions about the direction of investment.
“Worker protection should not always be portrayed as an obstacle to investment. The two should be able to go hand in hand,” Arif said.
Background to the passage of the Employment Protection Law
The House of Representatives (DPR RI) passed the latest Employment Protection Law on Tuesday (6 October 2026), following a revision process. The regulation was drafted after labour unions challenged the Job Creation Law, enacted in 2023. Workers’ organisations petitioned the Constitutional Court (MK) to review the law, arguing that several provisions harmed workers. The court subsequently upheld the challenge.
In its ruling, the Constitutional Court ordered the House and the government to revise the labour regulations. The process had to be completed by October 2026 at the latest. The resulting updated Employment Protection Law contains 23 chapters and 313 articles. Its passage prompted concern among business groups about the possible effects on investment decisions.
APINDO scrutinises the impact of the new rules
The Indonesian Employers Association (APINDO) is among those raising concerns about the regulation’s implications for the business climate. Its attention is focused in particular on provisions that could create greater uncertainty for companies. APINDO’s Head of Labour Affairs, Bob Azam, singled out severance pay as one issue requiring attention under the new rules. “On matters such as severance pay, we must ensure that investors are not deterred by provisions that create greater uncertainty,” Bob Azam told Kompas.com on Tuesday (10 November 2026).
APINDO said it was still reviewing all the provisions of the Employment Protection Law. The employers’ organisation is examining the articles one by one to assess the extent to which the regulation could affect investors.
The debate over the new labour rules therefore centres on two concerns: certainty for businesses and the protection of workers’ rights. APINDO is still assessing the regulation’s effects, while Arif argues that the two interests can be pursued together.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/labour-protections-do-not-deter-investment-observer-says-1794721825)
Originally published by limapagi.id (https://www.limapagi.id/pelindungan-buruh-investasi-indonesia), translated from Indonesian