Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Labour Bill Expands Criminal Sanctions, Increasing Legal Risks for Employers

| | Source: investortrust.id Translated from Indonesian | Regulation
Labour Bill Expands Criminal Sanctions, Increasing Legal Risks for Employers
Image: investortrust.id

The Draft Labour Law (RUU Ketenagakerjaan), currently under discussion between the House of Representatives (DPR RI) and the government, expands criminal provisions for employers. Several violations that previously fell under administrative categories now potentially face criminal sanctions.

Under the existing Labour Law No. 13/2003, criminal provisions were recorded in only six articles. However, in the proposed Draft Labour Law, the number of criminal articles has expanded to 33. This expansion is viewed as potentially increasing uncertainty for the business world, particularly amidst investor concerns regarding policy inconsistency and law enforcement in Indonesia.

In previous labour regulations, criminal provisions primarily covered serious and fundamental violations. Employers could face criminal charges for actions such as child labour exploitation, neglect of wage rights, or the use of foreign workers without permits.

However, in the proposed Draft Labour and Labour Law, criminal provisions may also encompass violations previously categorised as administrative. One such example relates to negligence in social security registration. Employers may also face criminal charges regarding the handling of personal documents between employers and employees.

Fitriana, a lecturer in State Administrative Law at the University of Indonesia Faculty of Law (FHUI), assesses that expanding criminal offences for administrative violations could more easily ensnare companies in the formal sector. This is because formal companies maintain labour documentation, reporting obligations, and are registered within supervisory systems.

With this condition, when administrative violations are elevated to criminal offences, companies that have been fulfilling their obligations and maintaining an administrative trail become the parties most easily identified. This is significant as the formal sector is a pillar of employment, providing social security, employment contracts, and wage certainty. Currently, the total formal workforce reaches 60 million people, or approximately 40% of the total working population.

She notes that disproportionate criminal threats risk causing formal companies to withhold permanent employment expansion and instead shift towards more flexible, looser work schemes. Such a condition could potentially reduce the quality of the employment relationships that labour regulations intend to protect.

“There needs to be a clear distinction between fundamental and serious rights violations and administrative violations, which are more appropriately subject to administrative sanctions,” Fitriana stated in a written statement on Tuesday (22/9/2026).

Fitriana emphasised that such a hierarchy of punishment is necessary to uphold basic criminal principles. This principle aligns with the national Criminal Code (KUHP) via Law No. 1/2023, which has been in effect since January 2026, as well as the direction of the Job Creation Law and the government’s deregulation agenda, which prioritises administrative sanctions. However, the Draft Labour Law is seen as moving in the opposite direction.

“Criminal law should serve as the ultimum remedium (the last resort),” she added.

The Draft Labour Law, which contains numerous criminal provisions, also opens the possibility of penalising not just management, but the entire corporate entity. Fitriങ്ങള്‍ noted that the threat of corporate criminal liability needs to be examined proportionally.

“In short, criminal acts and the perpetrators must be specifically proven. Who committed the act, or who ordered/allowed the violation to occur,” Fitriana explained.

For certain violations, Fitriana suggests the Draft Labour Law should be able to accommodate financial sanctions. “But in my view, we must also look at the type of violation and whether the sanction is effective for restoring rights [reparative] or preventing repeated violations [preventive],” she clarified.

Meanwhile, Muhammad Saleh, Director of Legal Affairs at the Centre of Economic & Law Studies (Celios), believes that legal certainty remains a major challenge in Indonesian law enforcement. He argues that the Draft Labour Law, once passed, must be applied consistently to avoid adding uncertainty to the business world.

“From the perspective of investment and law, economic sentiment and investor confidence fundamentally depend on the aspect of law enforcement. They observe the risk of inconsistent enforcement and uncertainty,” Saleh stated.

Saleh noted that investors in Indonesia currently face conditions where regulations frequently change. Furthermore, rules regarding law and licensing are deemed to still face issues during implementation. “Consequently, investors must incur legal costs due to uncertain legal matters,” said Saleh.

This issue becomes even more pressing given the current capacity of labour inspection. Data from the Ministry of Manpower shows only about 1,400 labour inspectors to oversee at least 400,000 medium-to-large companies, not including millions of other registered business entities.

This ratio is considered far below the standards set by the International Labour Organization (ILO). Therefore, Saleh stated that the government needs to consider how the Draft Labour Law can be applied consistently in the field.

Furthermore, Indonesia still faces issues with investment cost inefficiency. Referring to the Incremental Capital-Output Ratio (ICOR), Indonesia still records a score of 6.5, indicating a lower level of investment efficiency compared to major ASEAN neighbours, which have an average score of 4.

Licensing costs, weak law enforcement, illegal levies, and logistics costs for investors in Indonesia remain among the highest in the region. Given these conditions, Saleh believes that at the very least, the Draft Law…

More from 22 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/labour-bill-expands-criminal-sanctions-increasing-legal-risks-for-employers-1790088763)
Originally published by investortrust.id (https://investortrust.id/national/117050/ruu-ketenagakerjaan-perluas-sanksi-pidana-pengusaha-makin-dibayangi-risiko-hukum), translated from Indonesian
Print