Kupang District Court Rejects Pre-trial Motion by Three TTU Regional Council Members in Intimidation Case
The Class 1A Kupang District Court in East Nusa Tenggara (NTT) has rejected the pre-trial motion regarding the suspect designation filed by three members of the North Central Timor (TTU) Regional Legislative Council (DPRD) related to the alleged intimidation of Dr Eliza Princila Utami Pakaenoni (27), also known as Icha. The three suspects are Therensius Lazakar, Norbertus Tubani, and Veronika Lake.
The hearing was presided over by a single judge, Jantiani Longli Naetasi, on Tuesday (6/10/2026). In the verdict, Jantiani stated that the pre-trial application submitted by the three suspects was rejected.
“Rejecting the pre-trial application of the petitioners and charging the petitioners with court costs amounting to zero,” Jantiani stated in the verdict on Tuesday.
Jantiani explained that the petitioners argued the preliminary evidence for the suspect designation lacked relevance to the alleged criminal offence. She emphasised that the designation of the three TTU DPRD members was based on two valid pieces of preliminary evidence.
The judge also rejected the petitioners’ argument questioning their examination as suspects without prior written approval from the Governor of NTT, Emanuel Melkiades Laka Lena. The petitioners had based this argument on Constitutional Court (MK) Decision Number 76/PUU-XII/2014.
However, according to the judge, the MK decision does not automatically require the examination of district/city DPRD members to be conducted only after obtaining written approval from the governor. The judge considered that the Law on MPR, DPR, DPD, and DPRD (UU MD3) underwent amendments in 2018 and 2019.
These amendments, it was noted, did not adopt the legal considerations requiring the examination of district/city DPRD members to have the written approval of the governor. Therefore, the judge assessed that the previous provision was merely obiter dictum, not ratio decidendi.
The judge also applied the principle of lex posterior derogat legi priori, meaning newer law supersedes older law. Thus, even though MK Decision Number 76/PUU-XII/2014 is final and binding, its binding force has diminished over time alongside legislative changes.
“As it is not regulated in the amendments to the MD3 Law, the principle of lex posterior derogat legi priori applies, establishing that new law supersedes the application of old law,” explained Jantiani.
Another argument rejected by the judge was the objection to the suspect designation letters, which were claimed to lack a brief description of the case. The judge referred to the Suspect Designation Letters (S.Tap.Tsk/15/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum, S.Tap.Tsk/16/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum, and S.Tap.Tsk/17/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum) for Therensius Lazakar, Norbertus Tubani, and Veronika Lake, respectively. According to the judge, these three letters contained the suspects’ identities, the case chronology, the suspects’ rights, and notification of the designation to relevant parties.
In the chronology section, the letters stated that the petitioners became suspects in an alleged criminal offence against the person involving assault and/or threats using verbal violence. These actions allegedly caused the victim to suffer severe depression, subsequently leading to her death by suicide.
The alleged criminal incident reportedly took place in the Emergency Room (IGD) of the Leona-Kefamenanu General Hospital, Maubeli, Kefamenanu, TTU Regency, on 13 June 2026.
The victim reportedly ended her life by hanging in the RSS Baumata housing complex, West Baumata, Taebenu, Kupang Regency, on 26 June 2026. The letters also noted that the investigators designated the suspects after gathering and clarifying the occurrence of the criminal offence based on at least two pieces of evidence.
The petitioners also questioned the notification of the suspect designation to the Head of the NTT High Prosecutor’s Office and the complainant, arguing it contravened Article 90 paragraph (2) of the KUHAP. However, the judge asserted that the complainant can be informed to the extent of the follow-up on the reported alleged criminal offence.
“It does not contravene the values living in society and instead benefits the complainant by allowing them to know the extent of the follow-up regarding the reported alleged criminal offence,” concluded Jantiani.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kupang-district-court-rejects-pre-trial-motion-by-three-ttu-regional-council-members-in-intimidation-case-1791276835)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8694855/pn-kupang-tolak-praperadilan-3-anggota-dprd-ttu-di-kasus-intimidasi-dr-icha), translated from Indonesian