KPU Expert Argues Gibran's Diploma Lawsuit is Inappropriate Post-Inauguration
The General Elections Commission (KPU) presented constitutional law expert Khairul Fahmi as a witness in the case regarding the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Result Dispute (PHPU). In his capacity as an expert, Fahmi assessed that the lawsuit concerning Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s diploma is no longer appropriate when brought through the PHPU mechanism at the Constitutional Court (MK).
The hearing for case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 was held at the Constitutional Court building on Thursday (1/10/2026) evening. Fahmi initially presented his views regarding the lawsuit filed by the petitioners concerning Gibran’s diploma during his candidacy for the 2024 Vice Presidency.
Fahmi highlighted the need to limit the Constitutional Court’s authority in PHPU cases and addressed the legal standing of the petitioners. He argued that this limitation is crucial because the case essentially brings together two distinct legal regimes that should be clearly separated: election law and the law governing the office of the President and Vice President.
“The difference between these two legal regimes is not merely procedural, but also encompasses the consequences of a change in an individual’s legal status,” explained Fahmi.
Fahmi explained that prior to being inaugurated, an individual holds the status of a candidate, prospective candidate, or an elected candidate-pair. However, once inaugurated, the individual is no longer a candidate but holds the status and position of President or Vice President, as a constitutional office holder.
“In this regard, the first question to be answered is not whether there are issues regarding the candidacy requirements for a President or Vice President, but rather, once all election stages are completed and the elected President-Vice President has been inaugurated, can issues regarding candidacy requirements still be brought back into the regime of presidential election result disputes?” said Fahlam.
According to Fahmi, once all election stages are complete, the dispute over results has reached a final determination. He noted that the elected candidates have been officially established and inaugurated as President and Vice President, meaning issues regarding candidacy requirements cannot be retroactively applied to election law.
“This is not because alleged violations discovered later lose their legal relevance, but because there has been a change in legal status and a change in the legal regime governing them,” said Fahmi.
He stated that election result disputes are a mechanism to test the legality of electoral contest results within the limits of subject, object, and time as determined by the Constitution and the Election Law. Post-inauguration, an individual who was previously a candidate becomes a constitutional office holder.
“In this context, a PHPU petition after the election stages have ended cannot retroactively revert a sitting President or Vice President to being merely a candidate for the sole purpose of applying candidate disqualification rules. This is because disqualification applies to the status of a candidate, whereas removal mechanisms apply to the status of an official,” he revealed.
“If facts discovered after inauguration are deemed very serious such that they impact the continuity of the President’s or Vice President’s office, the issue has shifted from candidacy eligibility to a matter of constitutional office. Regarding this, the 1945 Constitution provides its own mechanism for resolution, namely Clauses 7A and 7B of the 1945 Constitution,” he added.
Based on this, Fahmi argued that the Constitutional Court’s authority to examine alleged violations related to the election process in PHPU cannot be equated with the authority to revive PHPU resolutions after they have concluded.
For him, once someone is inaugurated as President or Vice President, the legal question is no longer whether they are eligible for disqualification, but whether there are constitutional grounds to remove them from office.
“Because the legal status has changed, the governing legal regime is different, and the method of handling it has also changed,” he said.
“This boundary must be respected by anyone and any institution as an expression of adherence to the principles of constitutionalism enshrined in the 1945 Constitution,” he added.
The lawsuit was filed by former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights Denny Indrayana along with 11 other petitioners. The application was submitted on 10 September 2026 and officially registered by the MK on 17 September 2026 under case number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026.
The preliminary examination of the petition was held at the MK on Monday (21/9).
The respondent in this lawsuit is the KPU, with the Bawaslu (Election Supervisory Body) as a related party. There are 12 petitioners in this lawsuit, including Brahma Aryana, Ansufric ID Sambo, Denny Indrayana, Fachrul Razi, Tyasno Sudarto, Slamet Soebijanto, Hanafie Asnan, Soenarko MD, drg. Moeryono, H.M. Subhan, Bonatua Silalahi, and Dra. Tiurma M.S. Sihombing.
The petitioners argue that the alleged failure to meet Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements only recently came to light and that information was allegedly suppressed. The petitioners stated that if trial evidence shows Gibran meets the educational requirements, the Court may affirm the validity of his candidacy. Conversely, if evidence shows the requirements were not met, they expect the Court to issue a disqualification ruling.
“The petitioners are merely seeking a fair opportunity so that the juridical truth regarding the fulfillment of Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements at the time he was established as a Vice Presidential candidate can be tested through an evidentiary trial that is open, impartial, transparent, and accountable,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kpu-expert-argues-gibrans-diploma-lawsuit-is-inappropriate-post-inauguration-1790873811)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8688647/ahli-kpu-nilai-gugatan-ijazah-gibran-di-mk-tak-tepat-usai-jadi-wapres), translated from Indonesian