KPU Claims Lawsuit Regarding Gibran's Educational Requirements is 905 Days Overdue
The General Elections Commission (KPU) has assessed that the lawsuit regarding the dispute over the 2024 Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election results (PHPU), specifically concerning Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational requirements, has exceeded the prescribed deadline. The KPU estimates that the PHPU application is 905 days overdue.
This was stated by the KPU, acting as the Respondent, while presenting a response to PHPU lawsuit number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 at the Constitutional Court in Central Jakarta on Wednesday (23/9/2026). The KPU noted that the Petitioners have already acknowledged that the application exceeds the submission deadline.
“The Petitioners have admitted that their application was submitted late. This is stated on page 39, point 105. This admission by the Petitioners in their application serves as perfect and binding evidence against them. With such an admission, the formal requirements for submitting the application have lapsed without the need for further proof,” said the KPU’s legal counsel, Saleh.
The KPU stated that PHPU applications must be submitted no later than three days after the KPU announces the election results, which would have been no later than 23 March 2024. The KPU asserted that this is in accordance with Article 475, paragraph (1) of the Election Law and Article 7, paragraph (2) of the Constitutional Court Regulation Number 4 of 2023.
The KPU noted that the election results were finalised on 20 March 2024, meaning the deadline for submission was 23 March 2024. However, the Petitioners filed this application on 10 September 2026.
“The Petitioners’ reasoning as an attempt to seek justice cannot be justified if it is carried out by ignoring or bypassing legal provisions that have strictly regulated the time limits for submitting an application,” he said.
The KPU has requested the Court to reject the lawsuit. The KPU emphasised that based on Article 74, paragraph (1) letter b of the Constitutional Court Law, Article 475, paragraph (1) of the Election Law, and Article 3, paragraph (1) of PMK Number 3 of 2023, the authority to file PHPU disputes is strictly reserved for the presidential and vice-presidential candidate pairs participating in the election.
“The application should be rejected on its own, let alone since the application in question is 905 days late. We have prepared a table for Your Honours, showing the delays regarding various KPU decisions, starting from Decision 1632 regarding the determination of candidates on 13 November 2023. KPU Decision 1644 was issued on 14 November 2023, and KPU Decision 360 was issued on 20 March 2024,” he said.
“Finally, KPU Decision Number 504 was issued on 24 April 2024. The respective delays from these four objects are 1032 days, 1031 days, 905 days, and the delay regarding the determination of candidate pairs has exceeded 869 days. Therefore, legally, the application submitted by the Petitioners is clearly far beyond the submission deadline,” he continued.
The KPU also assessed that the Petitioners lack the legal standing to file the 2024 PHPU lawsuit. The KPU believes the Petitioners’ application is unclear and was filed with the incorrect institution.
The KPU argued that the reasoning of ‘fast and inexpensive justice’ cannot serve as a basis for transferring authority to the Constitutional Court. According to the KPU, this indicates that the Petitioners erred in determining the object and the institution authorised to adjudicate the matter, thus filing the application with the wrong body.
“The basis for a PHPU filing must essentially involve errors in vote counting and the correct comparison of vote results. However, the Petitioners are not contesting the vote tallies. This proves ambiguity regarding the object and type of the application,” he stated.
The KPU noted inconsistencies and ambiguity within the application. The KPU emphasised that KPU Regulation (PKPU) Number 19 of 2023 was issued in accordance with applicable legal provisions.
“Previously, the Petitioners argued that the flaw in Gibran’s candidacy was not merely administrative but also manipulative, based on a phrase in Article 18, paragraph (3) found in PKPU Number 19 of 2023. The Respondent states that the KPU is authorised in the formation of PKPU as regulated by PKPU Number 1 of 2022,” he concluded.
The complete prayer (petitum) of the KPU’s application is as follows:
In the exception:
- To accept and grant the Respondent’s exception in its entirety.
In the merits of the case:
To reject the Petitioners’ application in its entirety.
To declare KPU Decision Number 1632 of 2023 regarding the Determination of Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidate Pairs for the 2024 Election on 13 November 2023 as valid and in force.
To declare KPU Decision Number 1644 of 2023 regarding the Determination of the Sequence Number of Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidate Pairs for the 2024 Election on 14 November 2023 as valid and in force.
To declare KPU Decision Number 360 of 2024 regarding the Determination of the Results of the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election, Members of the House of Representatives, and so on, dated 20 March 2024, as valid and in force.
To declare KPU Decision Number 504 of 2024 regarding the Determination of the Elected Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidate Pairs in the 2024 Election on 24 April 2024 as valid and in force.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kpu-claims-lawsuit-regarding-gibrans-educational-requirements-is-905-days-overdue-1790175557)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8676347/kpu-sebut-gugatan-phpu-syarat-pendidikan-gibran-di-mk-terlambat-905-hari), translated from Indonesian