KPU-Bawaslu Recruitment Vulnerable to Political Intervention
The independence of election organisers cannot be guaranteed solely by selecting individuals of high integrity. The recruitment system must also be overhauled to ensure that the selection process for members of the KPU and Bawaslu is not easily influenced by political interests.
Jeirry Sumampow, Coordinator of the Indonesian Voters Committee and Secretary General of the GMKI Senior Association, believes this condition creates a paradox in the administration of democracy. While the KPU and Bawaslu are required to be independent guardians of the electoral process, the final stage of their recruitment remains within a political process.
“The issue of independence and integrity of election organisers cannot be resolved merely by finding good people. What is more fundamental is ensuring that the recruitment system allows good, competent, and independent individuals a genuine opportunity to be elected,” said Jeirry during a LIPTEKS PARKINDO discussion titled “Ensuring Correct and Integrity-Based Recruitment of KPU and Bawaslu,” held on Thursday (10/9).
Jeirry noted that this issue is becoming increasingly critical amidst the strengthening of political intervention, nepotism, patronage, and oligarchy within Indonesian democracy. He argued that these issues have the potential to influence not only political processes but also the recruitment mechanisms of election organisers.
“In Indonesian democratic life, political intervention, nepotlarism, patronage, and oligarchy are becoming stronger. This strong intervention is also occurring within the recruitment processes for election organisers, the KPU and Bawaslu,” he stated.
According to Jeirry, the design of the recruitment process is a fundamental issue that must be addressed. Because the final decision regarding KPU and Bawaslu members rests with political institutions, there is a risk that the independence of organisers is compromised from the very beginning by political interests.
He reminded that the positions of the KPU and Bawaslu are highly strategic, as both institutions act as the gatekeepers of democracy. The KPU and Bawaslu determine the nomination process, ensure that votes are processed according to regulations, and handle various issues within election administration.
Therefore, Jeirry argued that recruitment reform must go beyond merely replacing figures. Changes must target the system that allows political intervention to occur during the selection process. “Therefore, reform must not stop at changing people. What must be improved is the system,” he emphasised.
Jeirry proposed several mechanisms to strengthen this process, including transparency in criteria and the basis for candidate ranking, track-record audits, substantive public participation, and a mechanism for public objections against election organiser candidates.
Furthermore, candidates proven to have conflicts of interest or political dependencies should be automatically eliminated. Such a mechanism is deemed essential to prevent selection processes from merely producing figures who meet administrative requirements but lack substantive independence.
Jeirry also assessed that independence cannot be measured solely by whether a person is not a member of a political party. Formal status does not automatically indicate that a person is free from political influence.
“True independence is seen in a person’s ability to say ‘no’ to power when political pressure contradicts the law, justice, and the public interest,” he said.
Consequently, civil society is encouraged not only to monitor the stages and results of elections but also to pay close attention to the process that determines who will become the election organisers.
“We urge civil society to not only monitor election results but also to monitor the entry point. The recruitment of election organisers must become a serious agenda for democratic reform,” said Jeirry.
He emphasised that the quality of elections ultimately depends on the integrity of the people and the system behind their administration. If the recruitment process continues to leave too much room for political interests, the demand for organisers to be fully independent will be difficult to realise.
“Because election integrity begins with the integrity of the process that selects its organisers. Do not ask for an independent referee if the participants of the match still possess too much authority to choose the referee themselves,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kpu-bawaslu-recruitment-vulnerable-to-political-intervention-1789661266)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/934673/rekrutmen-kpu-bawaslu-rentan-intervensi-politik), translated from Indonesian