Koperasi Merah Putih: Strategic Partner or New Competitor for Small Businesses?
New Hope or Merely Another New Programme?
“Yet another new programme from the government.” We have probably all heard that sentence, or even said it ourselves. Whenever a policy is launched, the public response is almost always divided in two. Some welcome it with optimism, while others prefer to wait for concrete evidence before placing their trust.
Something similar has happened with the arrival of the Merah Putih Village/Sub-district Cooperatives (Koperasi Desa/Kelurahan Merah Putih). Since being introduced as one of the national strategic programmes, its name has been the subject of constant discussion. Some see it as a breath of fresh air for the village economy, but many also question whether the programme will truly bring change or simply make a noisy start before slowly being forgotten.
Behind this debate lies one fact that cannot be ignored: many villages in Indonesia have enormous economic potential but have not been able to manage it optimally. Farmers often sell their harvests at low prices because they depend on middlemen. Micro, small and medium enterprise (MSME) actors struggle to grow their businesses due to limited capital, market access and mentoring. Meanwhile, long distribution chains mean consumer prices are far higher than the prices received by producers.
Based on these conditions, the government established the Merah Putih Cooperatives as an effort to strengthen the village economy through a people-based economic approach. Under government policy, these cooperatives are designed not merely as savings and loan institutions, but also as centres for distributing basic necessities, marketing local products, managing agricultural produce, and strengthening micro and small businesses. The hope is that village communities will no longer act individually, but instead have a shared vehicle capable of improving their bargaining position and the welfare of their members.
These expectations certainly sound promising. The government is optimistic that the cooperatives can shorten distribution chains, widen access to financing, create jobs and encourage more independent and sustainable village economic growth. If managed well, the cooperatives could even become the engine of local economies capable of narrowing the gap between villages and cities.
On the other hand, communities have expectations that are simpler but vitally important. They do not merely want to see cooperatives established administratively or inaugurated with a ceremony. What they truly await are real benefits: better harvest prices, easier access to capital, wider product marketing and increased family incomes.
This is where the greatest challenge for the Merah Putih Cooperatives lies. Their success will not be measured by how many cooperatives are formed, but by the size of their impact on people’s lives. Can this programme become a turning point in the revival of the village economy, or will it instead repeat the old problems experienced by many Indonesian cooperatives? It is this question that keeps the Merah Putih Cooperatives a compelling topic for discussion.
Opportunity or Threat? Weighing the Impact of Merah Putih Cooperatives on MSMEs and Small Businesses
Behind the great expectations for the Merah Putih Cooperatives, various critical questions have also emerged from the public. Some see the programme as a golden opportunity to revive the village economy, whilst others still harbour doubts. These differing views are natural, because every major policy brings both opportunity and challenge.
On one hand, the presence of the Merah Putih Cooperatives has the potential to strengthen the economic position of village communities. One long-standing problem faced by farmers, fishermen and MSME actors is their weak bargaining position in the distribution chain. Many harvests or business products must be sold to intermediaries at low prices due to limited market access. As a result, the profits received by producers are far smaller than the value paid by consumers.
Through cooperatives, these conditions are expected to change. By pooling the strength of many members, cooperatives have the opportunity to purchase produce collectively, provide storage warehouses, assist distribution and open up wider marketing access. If run professionally, cooperatives can become a bridge between producers and markets, so that more of the economic value added is enjoyed by village communities themselves.
Not only that, cooperatives can also offer a solution to financing problems. Many micro-business owners still struggle to obtain credit from formal financial institutions due to limited collateral or administrative requirements. The cooperatives are expected to provide easier access to financing accompanied by business mentoring, so that members receive not only capital but also education on financial management and business development.
However, behind these various potentials, there are a number of concerns that cannot be ignored. One is the possibility of overlapping functions with cooperatives established earlier, as well as with Village-Owned Enterprises (BUMDes). If coordination does not go well, the presence of multiple economic institutions in villages could create unhealthy competition rather than complement one another.
Another concern comes from small business owners, such as grocery shopkeepers, staple food traders and local distributors. Some of them wonder whether the cooperatives will eventually become partners that strengthen their businesses, or instead turn into new competitors with far greater backing. This question deserves attention, because the success of a development programme should not come at the expense of businesses that have long been people’s source of livelihood.
In the author’s view, cooperatives should be positioned as drivers of the economic ecosystem, not as players who dominate the market. In other words, cooperatives need to build partnerships with local businesses. For example, cooperatives can act as suppliers of goods for grocery shops, help promote MSME products, or serve as distribution centres connecting producers with traders. With such a model, all economic actors benefit without having to put one another out of business.
In the digital era, these opportunities are even more open. Cooperatives no longer have to be synonymous with manual bookkeeping or slow service. Through the use of digital technology, cooperatives can manage administration more transparently, provide digital payment services and even market members’ products through online platforms. This transformation will widen MSMEs’ market reach whilst increasing public trust in cooperative management.
Even so, technology is only a tool. The most decisive factors remain the quality of human resources and organisational governance. Cooperative administrators are required to have integrity, managerial capability and a commitment to prioritising members’ interests. Without professional management, cooperatives risk repeating the problems of the past, such as low member participation, weak transparency and declining public trust.
Ultimately, the pros and cons surrounding the Merah Putih Cooperatives are a natural part of a development process. Criticism should not be viewed as rejection, but as a reminder for the programme to stay on course. Conversely, support must be accompanied by oversight so that the cooperatives genuinely become an instrument of community empowerment, not merely a project that generates noise at the start.
Therefore, the question worth reflecting on together is no longer whether the Merah Putih Cooperatives are needed or not. The more important question is how to ensure these cooperatives grow into partners for MSMEs and small businesses, rather than competitors that narrow their commercial space. The answer to that question will largely determine whether the Merah Putih Cooperatives truly become the engine of a people-based economy, or simply one more programme that loses direction once public attention shifts elsewhere.
Learning from the Past, Looking to the Future: Can the Merah Putih Cooperatives Be a Turning Point?
When discussing cooperatives in Indonesia, we actually have a long history. Unfortunately, that journey has not always been smooth. Many cooperatives were born with great enthusiasm, only to lose their way due to weak governance, low member participation and a lack of transparency in financial management. As a result, public trust in cooperatives gradually declined.
This lesson should serve as important provision for the Merah Putih Cooperatives. The programme cannot be measured merely by the number of cooperatives established or the size of the budget allocated. Its success will actually be visible when communities truly feel the benefits, from rising farmer incomes and growing MSMEs to the creation of new jobs in villages. Various studies also emphasise that the success of the Merah Putih Cooperatives depends heavily on professional governance, visionary leadership and active member participation.
From the perspective of Islamic economics, the idea of the Merah Putih Cooperatives aligns with the principles of ta’awun (mutual assistance), ’adl (justice) and maslahah (collective benefit). Islam views economic activity not merely as a means of obtaining profit, but also as a way to create equitable prosperity. Therefore, cooperatives managed with integrity, transparency and commitment to their members can become one form of implementing Islamic economic values in everyday life.
However, these values will remain mere slogans if they are not realised in practice. Transparency in financial reporting, strong oversight, member education and the use of digital technology must become the working culture of the cooperatives. That way, the Merah Putih Cooperatives will not only be known as a government programme, but also as an economic institution trusted by the public.
Ultimately, the Merah Putih Cooperatives are not merely about building new cooperatives, but about rebuilding public trust in the spirit of gotong royong (mutual cooperation) that has always been the nation’s identity. This programme has a great opportunity to strengthen the village economy, but it also faces considerable challenges. Its success will be determined by consistency of implementation, quality of management and the active involvement of communities as the cooperatives’ owners.
So, what do you think? Will the Merah Putih Cooperatives become a new milestone in the revival of Indonesia’s people-based economy, or will they face the same challenges as previous cooperatives? This discussion matters, because the success of cooperatives is not only the government’s responsibility, but also that of all the communities who will be part of this journey.
In the end, the Merah Putih Cooperatives are not merely about building thousands of new cooperatives or running a government programme. Far more important is how this programme can bring real change to people’s lives. Cooperatives will find their meaning when farmers receive fairer selling prices, MSMEs flourish, jobs multiply and village communities have greater opportunities to improve their welfare.
However, these hopes will not materialise through regulations or large budgets alone. The success of the Merah Putih Cooperatives depends on professional governance, transparency, the integrity of administrators and active community participation as both members and owners. Without all of these, the programme risks repeating the challenges experienced by cooperatives in the past.
Now, the question is no longer whether the Merah Putih Cooperatives are a good idea or not. The more important question is: can we collectively nurture and build cooperatives that genuinely side with the people? For the success of cooperatives is not only the government’s responsibility, but also ours as citizens who wish to see the people’s economy grow stronger.
So, what is your view? Will the Merah Putih Cooperatives become a milestone in the revival of village economies and MSMEs in Indonesia, or will they face the same challenges as previous programmes? Let us share our perspectives and discuss, because it is from diverse viewpoints that ideas emerge to refine policy for the common good.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/koperasi-merah-putih-strategic-partner-or-new-competitor-for-small-businesses-1783587111)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/769958/koperasi-merah-putih-mitra-strategis-atau-pesaing-baru-pengusaha-kecil), translated from Indonesian