Komnas Perempuan Apologises After Saying YTR Case Not Torture Under UN Definition
Komnas Perempuan has apologised regarding its statements concerning the case of a woman in Bandung, YTR, who was subjected to abuse for three years, stating that the incident does not fall under the category of torture as defined by the United Nations. The Commission maintains that the case constitutes extreme, sadistic, and cruel multi-layered violence that degrades human dignity.
“Komnas Perempuan understands the immense public attention surrounding the YTR case in Bandung. Therefore, Komnas Perempuan offers a sincere apology regarding our statements made during the International Day Against Torture Press Conference on 2int 26 June 2026, which discussed the case within the framework of the Convention against Torture (CAT),” stated the Vice Chair of Komnas Perempuan, Ratna Batara Munti, in a written statement on the official website on Monday (29/6/2026).
Komnas Perempuan stated that the YTR case is a form of extreme, sadistic, and cruel multi-layered gender-based violence against women (GBV) that meets the elements of severe physical assault under criminal law. In the everyday understanding of the public, such actions are also viewed as torture due to the level of cruelty and suffering inflicted.
The Commission emphasised that its primary focus has never changed: to oversee the protection, recovery, and fulfilment of the victim’s rights, and to support law enforcement in delivering justice.
The previous explanation provided during the press conference was made within the context of discussing the Convention against Torture, which was ratified through Law Number 5 of 1998. Article 1 of this law defines torture as being committed by state officials or non-state actors if there is state complicity or negligence. Therefore, Komnas Perempuan stated that the explanation was not intended to minimise the severity of the violence or the suffering experienced by the victim.
“The fact is, this case has resulted in extraordinary suffering and permanent disability for the victim, as well as profound physical, psychological, and economic losses,” said Komnas Perempuan.
Furthermore, the Commission expressed support for the various parties, including hospitals, caregivers, the community, local government, and law enforcement, who acted swiftly to ensure the victim received proper care.
It was previously reported that Komnas Perempuan Commissioner, Sondang Frishka Simanjuntak, stated that the confinement and abuse of YTR by Taufik Hidayat in Bandung did not constitute torture. Simanjuntak noted that the definition of torture in this case did not fall within the categories established by the United Nations Convention Against Torture.
These remarks were made during the International Day Against Torture event at the Ombudsman Office in Jakarta on Friday (26/6/2026). In response to the public outcry, Komnas Perempuan addressed the YTR case specifically.
“Regarding the YTR case, we must state here that we cannot yet view the YTR case as a case of torture under the definition of the Convention Against Torture. The Convention requires that the act be intended to inflict severe pain to achieve a specific purpose,” Simanjutak said during a Q&A session with journalists, as seen on the Ombudsman RI YouTube account on Sunday (28/6/2026).
She noted that under the UN Convention concept, the definition of torture involves purposes such as obtaining a confession or discrimination, and requires state involvement. Simanjuntak raised the question of whether there was any negligence by the state in this instance.
“The purpose is, for example, to obtain a confession or for discrimination, and there is state involvement. In the YTR case, we have seen that there were indeed actions that caused severe pain. The impact is truly extraordinary,” said Simanjuntak.
“What we need to examine now is whether there was any oversight, for instance, by the local government regarding her boarding house, or by law enforcement. For example, if the victim attempted to report the case but it was not followed up,” she added.
She stated that state negligence in the YTR case still needs to be investigated further. Komnas Perempuan has committed to monitoring the case by deploying a team to Bandung.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/komnas-perempuan-apologises-after-saying-ytr-case-not-torture-under-un-definition-1782719604)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8552061/komnas-perempuan-minta-maaf-usai-sebut-kasus-ytr-belum-masuk-penyiksaan-versi-pbb), translated from Indonesian