Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

KNKT Announces Findings on KRL and Argo Bromo Anggrek Collision

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Infrastructure
KNKT Announces Findings on KRL and Argo Bromo Anggrek Collision
Image: CNBC Indonesia

The National Transportation Safety Committee (KNKT) has finally released the investigation results of the collision between a commuter rail (KRL) and the Argo Brolmo Anggrek train that occurred in Bekasi Timur, West Java. In the document released by the KNKT, several causes for the accident that took place on 27 April 2026 were identified.

The 141-page document was released by the Chairman of the KNKT, Soerjanto Tjahjono. In the report, the KNKT noted several contributing factors that led to the collision of the two trains.

“Contributing factors are actions, conditions, events, or a combination thereof which, if removed, avoided, or absent, would reduce the possibility of an accident or reduce the severity of an accident. The identification of contributing factors is not intended to establish fault or responsibility in an administrative, civil, or criminal sense,” the KNKT wrote, as cited on Monday (28/9/2026).

The first point identified was the failure to identify hazard conditions in the signalling relationship between Bekasi Station and Bekasi Timur Station. In its report, the KNKT stated that at the time of the accident, train 4B (Argo Bromo Anggrek) was permitted to proceed directly from Track III of Bekasi Station through Exit Signal J12, which showed a green aspect, followed by Block Signal B104, which showed a red aspect because train 556larA (KRL TM6000) was still present at Bekasi Timur Station (track 104BT).

Under these conditions, the driver of train 4B did not receive a signal showing a yellow aspect to inform them that the subsequent signal would show a red aspect. This condition was not identified during the design review and testing phases following the layout changes at Bekasi Station in 2021. In the 2022 design review document, the signalling aspects were depicted in a signal-to-signal relationship without track occupancy status; therefore, the differing behaviour of Exit Signal J12 relative to the occupancy status of track 104AT and/or 104BT was not illustrated.

Because this was not depicted, the condition remained unidentified from the design review and testing stages through to operations, until this accident occurred.

The second point concerned communication issues during the emergency. The investigation found that when the driver of train 5181B contacted the South PPKP (Train Controller) to report the collision at JPL 86, the call was made via an individual call by pressing the PTT button on the microphone without pressing the emergency call button.

From communication recordings, it was known that the clarification process regarding the condition of train 5181B and the affected tracks took 3 minutes and 20 seconds before it was fully understood by the South PPKP. The investigation found issues with the audio output of train 5181B, specifically reverb, warbling, and relatively low volume because the distance between the sound source and the microphone exceeded the recommended distance in the Radio Tait TM9000 Operational Instructions.

This condition reduced the audibility of the audio output from train 5181B and affected the ability of the South PPKP to receive information from the train. The investigation also found that current procedures do not regulate the standard use of terminology (phraseology) in communications or the structure of delivering emergency information from drivers to the PPKP.

The call being made via an individual rather than an emergency call, combined with reduced audibility and the lack of standardised phraseology and emergency reporting procedures, resulted in increased information delivery duration and affected the South PPKP’s assessment of the emergency level, thereby influencing decisions regarding train control during the situation.

The third point was the communication failure regarding train 55682 (TM6000). A communication failure occurred where information that train 5568A was held at Bekasi Timur Station due to a crowd of people was not conveyed to the PPKP, as the South PPKP was busy handling an incident at JPL 86. The driver of train 5568A contacted the South PPKP via an individual call rather than an emergency call, meaning no emergency call notification appeared on the radio console at the South PPKP control desk.

As a result of this communication failure, neither the South PPKP nor the East PPKP received information regarding the situation and service disruptions at Bekasi Timur Station, leaving the controllers without adequate information to make appropriate decisions regarding train control at that time.

The fourth point was the lack of an information sharing mechanism between the South PPKP and the East PPKP. The investigation found no procedure regulating the mechanism for information exchange between these two controllers.

In this incident, the East PPKP learned about the accident at JPL 86 by overhearing the communication between the South PPKP and train 5181B, but did not receive complete information regarding the surrounding situation. This led to inaccurate information and commands being issued by the East PPKP to train 4B, leaving the driver of train 4B without sufficient information to take appropriate action.

The fifth point was the failure to identify the aspect of the UB104 Auxiliary Signal. The understanding held by the driver and assistant driver of train 4B, after passing the green aspect at Exit Signal J12 of Bekasi Station, influenced their attention allocation. Having the understanding that the next signal still showed an aspect permitting travel, and with no scheduled stops until Cirebon, the attention of the driver and assistant driver tended to be focused on information supporting that understanding. Consequently, the aspect shown by the auxiliary signal…

More from 28 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/knkt-announces-findings-on-krl-and-argo-bromo-anggrek-collision-1790589450)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260928161851-4-771518/breaking-knkt-umumkan-hasil-temuan-tabrakan-krl-argo-bromo-anggrek), translated from Indonesian
Print