KBPP Polri Chief: Criticism is Permissible, Insults Are Not
The General Chairman of the Keluarga Besar Putra-Putri (KBPP) Polri, AH Bimo Suryono, stated that critiquing policies that require improvement is a constitutional right of citizens, but warned against making insults a new culture within Indonesian democracy.
“Because when ethics disappear from the public sphere, it is not only the authority of leaders that collapses, but also the quality of democracy, national unity, and public trust in state institutions,” he said in a statement in Jakarta on Monday.
He highlighted recent political, economic, and social conditions, including waves of student protests criticising economic policies. One of the primary points of criticism from the protesters involved the Free Nutritious Meal (MBG) programme, with calls for its abolition.
According to him, the necessary course of action is to evaluate, improve governance, tighten supervision, and ensure the programme reaches the intended targets, rather than summarily abolishing a programme aimed at improving the nutritional quality of Indonesian children and supporting the accelerated reduction of stunting rates, which is a priority in the national development agenda.
“A programme as large as the MBG certainly requires refinement. However, evaluation must be conducted objectively based on data, not merely through political narratives,” he emphasised.
He noted that democracy also demands maturity in delivering criticism. Criticising the President is the right of every citizen; however, criticism should be directed at government policies and performance, rather than transforming into attacks on personal honour.
Regardless of the various interpretations of such statements, he said the public sphere should be filled with arguments based on data, academic studies, and constructive ideas.
Intellectual tradition is not built through diction that could be perceived as insults, but through arguments capable of providing solutions for the nation.
He stated that students serve as both agents of change and a moral force. Therefore, the voices of students will be more respected if delivered through scientific argument, accurate data, good ethics, and constructive solutions.
“This nation needs criticism that enlightens, not narratives that exacerbate the situation,” said Bimo.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kbpp-polri-chief-criticism-is-permissible-insults-are-not-1781549469)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5609707/ketum-kbpp-polri-kritik-boleh-menghina-jangan), translated from Indonesian