Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

KAI Ethics Council Dismisses All Complaints, Finds Bildad Thonak Not Guilty

| Source: detikBali Translated from Indonesian | Legal
KAI Ethics Council Dismisses All Complaints, Finds Bildad Thonak Not Guilty
Image: detikBali

The Indonesian Advocates Congress (KAI) Ethics Council has dismissed all complaints against lawyer Bildad Thonak. It found him not guilty of the allegations brought by Izhak Rihi and his lawyer, Fransisco Bessi.

The ruling was delivered by the ethics panel led by Paul Seran Tahu, with Helda Puling Bola and Niko Lay Rihi as members.

After the ruling, Thonak said the ethics council had found him not guilty of the allegations made by complainant Izhak Rihi and his lawyer, Fransisco Bessi.

“In principle, the ethics council has ruled that, in its verdict, I was not found guilty of the allegations made by the complainant,” Thonak said.

He said the allegations included promising his former client, Izhak Rihi, that he would win his case.

“Allegations such as deception, promising a victory and providing false information have all been refuted by the ethics panel’s considerations,” he added.

Thonak also thanked the complainant for exercising his legal rights.

“I am grateful to the complainant, fellow lawyer Mr Fransisco Bessi, and my former client Izhak Rihi for exercising their legal rights. That is good for the organisation’s processes,” he said.

Meanwhile, Thonak’s lawyer, Amos Lafu, said the ethics council’s verdict dismissed the complaint in its entirety.

“As counsel for our client, Mr Bildad Thonak, first of all we thank God that, after a lengthy hearing, a decision has now been delivered. The ethics panel’s verdict dismisses the complainant’s complaint in its entirety,” Amos said.

He added that, because the complaint had been dismissed, none of the allegations against his client had been proven.

“If it is dismissed, then legally all the grounds set out in the complaint are understood to have not been proven,” he said.

Amos said a notable point in the panel’s reasoning was that the relationship between a client and a lawyer acting under a power of attorney is based on rights and obligations.

“This ethics ruling establishes that a lawyer cannot be held at fault simply because a client loses a case. Lawyers are not responsible for whether a client wins or loses; the authorised panel of judges has the power to decide a case,” Amos said.

“A lawyer’s task is to persuade the panel with evidence,” he added.

He said the panel’s reasoning also referred to outstanding legal fees owed by Thonak’s client.

“Under the agreement, our client was entitled to Rp500 million in fees, of which only Rp350 million has been paid. Rp150 million remains outstanding. That is our client’s right to claim,” he said.

Amos said they would consider legal action to recover the outstanding fees from Izhak Rihi.

“We will consider taking legal steps, including issuing a formal demand for payment of the remaining fees in accordance with today’s ruling. We will also consider criminal proceedings to restore our client’s standing in response to the allegations and defamation that have seriously damaged his reputation,” Amos said.

Meanwhile, Izhak Rihi’s side, represented by his lawyer Fransisco Bernando Bessi, said it respected the ethics council’s decision but would appeal to KAI’s national board in Jakarta.

“The ethics panel has delivered its decision today. As the complainant and counsel, we respect it. Once we receive the official copy of the ruling, we will lodge an appeal with KAI’s national board in Jakarta,” Bessi said.

He said the panel had failed to consider evidence submitted by the complainant.

“Our grounds for appeal are that our evidence was not considered. First, this concerns testimony from witness Paul Adrian Amalo and the chat messages between him and the respondent. The evidence submitted by the complainant concerning the respondent was also formally authenticated in accordance with the rules, and the testimony of expert witness Marvel Radja was not considered. We therefore declare that we will appeal,” he said.

More from 19 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/kai-ethics-council-dismisses-all-complaints-finds-bildad-thonak-not-guilty-1792403427)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8714077/majelis-etik-kai-tolak-seluruh-aduan-bildad-thonak-dinyatakan-tak-bersalah), translated from Indonesian
Print