Justice Saldi Fears AI Could Weaken Young People’s Skills
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Constitutional Court (MK) Deputy Chief Justice Saldi Isra voiced concern that the unwise use of artificial intelligence (AI) could weaken young people’s skills and their ability to improve their competitiveness in the workplace and education.
Saldi said using AI as an aid was acceptable, provided it did not extinguish young people’s habits of reading, writing and communicating effectively, particularly on matters involving constitutional rights.
“I am among those concerned about AI and its derivatives. Perhaps one day none of us will come to court any more. So I believe that as long as AI is used as an aid and does not kill those three things, that is fine,” Saldi said at the Open House and Ngopi Bareng #Courtizen Volume V talk show, held at the Constitutional Court’s Building I in Jakarta on Wednesday (28 October) to mark Youth Pledge Day.
Saldi said AI could lead people to stop attending court: they might simply enter their data into an AI system and receive an answer. That would be the end of it, he said.
He said a judgment delivered by a judge differed from one generated by AI because judges had feelings, while AI did not. Judges could tell whether someone in the courtroom was lying, he said.
In academic circles, he said, AI was already starting to be abandoned. He cited a lecturer friend in Australia who had begun teaching using conventional methods.
“They conducted a survey, comparing one class that used AI with another that worked manually. It turned out that the students who worked manually had far stronger analytical skills than those who used AI and similar tools,” he said.
Saldi urged young people not to let AI control them, saying its use was acceptable only as an aid. If students simply entered an assignment into AI and received a completed paper, their writing skills would not develop, he said.
The justice, who is from West Sumatra, said he did not use AI, except for the online version of the Great Dictionary of the Indonesian Language (KBBI).
“Why? Because I don’t want my skills to be replaced by AI,” he said.
Saldi assured the public that no Constitutional Court ruling had been produced using AI. All rulings, he said, were made by the nine constitutional justices through the judges’ deliberation meeting (RPH) process and written without AI assistance.
The justices, including Saldi, sometimes needed conventional books to consult when determining their legal positions.
When a petition is filed with the Court and the hearing concludes, the nine justices discuss it, after which each constitutional justice prepares their own legal opinion, he said.
At the RPH, the justices decide who will act as the drafter and prepare a draft ruling, working with a substitute registrar.
The registrar and the judge-drafter prepare the draft, which is then brought to the RPH. The petition and the legal reasoning are read out in full, word by word.
The RPH process reveals whether any judge’s opinion has been left out of the draft. The justices then revise the draft together, making AI interference difficult, he said.
To demonstrate that AI has not been used, he said, rulings include two dates: the date they were decided and the date they were pronounced.
He added that one part of a judge’s work could not be replaced by AI: human feeling. Judges can sense who is lying and who is not, and identify people who lie repeatedly in court, he said.
“When someone is lying, what they said at the beginning will eventually be exposed by inconsistencies later on, and that is something AI cannot detect,” Saldi said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/justice-saldi-fears-ai-could-weaken-young-peoples-skills-1793213450)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5818207/hakim-saldi-khawatir-ai-melemahkan-keahlian-generasi-muda), translated from Indonesian