Jumhur: Environmental Work Must Be More Than Counting Saplings and Holding Seminars
MEDAN — Indonesia’s Environment Minister and Head of the Environmental Control Agency, Moh Jumhur Hidayat, has sharply criticised organisations and institutions for how they measure the success of social and environmental programmes. He said that holding seminars, distributing emergency aid or planting thousands of tree seedlings often amounted to little more than figures on paper.
At the same time, he added, these activities did not necessarily bring about real change in people’s lives. Jumhur also discussed the meaning of Al-Ma’un theology in the modern era.
He asked the audience to imagine a familiar social reality: a rubbish-filled river suddenly goes viral on social media, prompting thousands of expressions of concern and messages of support. Yet people living nearby still have to contend with polluted water, children whose schooling is disrupted by floods, and small traders who lose their livelihoods.
“Concern is there. But people’s lives do not necessarily change,” Jumhur said during a public lecture at the 2026 graduation ceremony of the University of Muhammadiyah North Sumatra (UMSU) in Medan, North Sumatra, on Tuesday (27 October 2026). Muhammadiyah Central Board chairman Prof Dr H Dadang Kahmad and UMSU Rector Prof Dr Akrim Lubis were also present.
Jumhur recalled the essence of Al-Ma’un theology, passed down by Muhammadiyah’s founder, KH Ahmad Dahlan. He said the commitment to supporting disadvantaged people must not stop at short-term charity, but should be transformed into structural empowerment.
As an example, Jumhur said that organising 100 business training sessions was an activity achievement. But it did not demonstrate empowerment unless there were answers to fundamental questions: had family incomes risen, and were the businesses still operating a year later?
Jumhur also outlined the concept of “Ecological Repentance” to thousands of students at the University of Muhammadiyah North Sumatra. On environmental issues, he said, damage to nature always has a direct impact on social justice — from threats to family health and children losing study time because of recurrent floods, to the collapse of livelihoods for poorer residents.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/jumhur-environmental-work-must-be-more-than-counting-saplings-and-holding-seminars-1793094726)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tnk5dh484/jumhur-kegiatan-lingkungan-jangan-cuma-hitung-bibit-dan-seminar), translated from Indonesian