Judicial Review of 'Sorcery Clause' Ends After Petitioners Withdraw Case
The Constitutional Court has ruled that the application for the judicial review of Article 252, paragraph (1) of Law Number 1 of 2023 regarding the Criminal Code—commonly known as the ‘Sorcery Clause’—has been withdrawn by the petitioners.
According to the minutes of the Court’s decision in Jakarta on Wednesday, the judicial review was filed by five law students from Pamulang University. The petitioners withdrew their application because they were unable to adequately outline specific, actual, or potential constitutional losses, noting that their grievances remained purely academic.
“The Judges’ Deliberation Meeting on 22 September concluded that the withdrawal of application Number 327/PUU-XXIV/2026 is legally justified. Consequently, the petitioners may not re-submit the application in question,” stated Suhartoyo during the announcement of the decision in Jakarta on Tuesday (29/9).
The petition was filed by Bambang Sujatmiko, alongside Andika Firmanta Sitepu, Reka Violyta Priti Sari, Ayu Novalia Sundari, and Audia Rahman, to challenge the phrase “giving hope” within Article 252, paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code.
The article regulates any individual who claims to possess supernatural powers and uses such claims to notify, give hope, offer, or provide services to others, suggesting their actions can cause illness, death, or mental or physical suffering. Such acts are punishable by a maximum of one year and six months in prison or a fine of up to category IV.
The petitioners previously argued that the phrase “giving hope” lacked clear boundaries, parameters, or metrics to define what constitutes a criminal offence. “The existence of the phrase ‘giving an expectation’ without clear parameters fails to provide an adequate limiting function on the authority of law enforcement officers in determining whether the elements of a crime have been met,” Bambang stated during the preliminary hearing on Tuesday (8/9).
The application was subsequently withdrawn as the petitioners admitted that the losses they experienced to date were merely academic. The confirmation of this withdrawal took place during a session originally scheduled for the amendment of the petition.
The judicial review had garnered significant attention during preliminary hearings due to its focus on norms regarding supernatural powers, often referred to as the ‘Sorcery Clause’.
During the proceedings, Constitutional Court Deputy Chairman Saldi Isra questioned the legal standing of the petitioners and their connection to those targeted by the norm in Article 252, paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code. “So, anyone who claims to have supernatural powers. Do you possess supernatural powers?” Saldis asked.
Another judge, Adies, questioned whether any of the petitioners had ever performed sorcery, been a victim of sorcery, or studied under a sorcerer. The petitioners replied that they had never done so. “Therefore, we are also confused as to where your legal standing lies,” Adies remarked.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judicial-review-of-sorcery-clause-ends-after-petitioners-withdraw-case-1790744767)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5764277/uji-pasal-santet-di-mk-berakhir-setelah-pemohon-tarik-perkara), translated from Indonesian