Judicial Ethics Panel Dismisses Judge INS with Pension Rights for 129 Days’ Unauthorised Absence
Jakarta (ANTARA) – A hearing of the Judicial Honour Council (MKH) imposed the sanction of permanent dismissal with pension rights on INS, a judge at Cibinong District Court who had been assigned as a judicial judge at the Bandung High Court.
INS was sanctioned with permanent dismissal with pension rights after being found guilty of indiscipline for failing to attend work for 129 working days without a valid reason.
“The panel imposes a severe sanction on the reported judge, namely permanent dismissal with pension rights,” MKH presiding judge Jupriyadi said in a written statement received in Jakarta on Tuesday.
Jupriyadi delivered the ruling at an MKH hearing held by the Supreme Court (MA) and the Judicial Commission (KY) on Monday (19 October).
The panel comprised four KY members: Abhan, Setyawan Hartono, Willem Saija and Anita Kadir. The MA was represented by three Supreme Court justices: Jupriyadi, Budi Nugroho and Lucas Prakoso.
The ruling was issued in INS’s absence, after he had been duly and properly summoned twice to appear before the panel.
The hearing found that the disciplinary violation began when INS failed to comply with a severe disciplinary penalty imposed in August 2023: a two-year suspension from hearing cases at the Southeast Sulawesi High Court.
INS was last recorded as present on 6 September 2023, when he signed for receipt of the decision letter imposing the disciplinary penalty at Cibinong District Court.
During inspections by the Supreme Court’s Supervisory Agency on 23 February and 13 March 2024, INS was recorded as having been absent for 129 days. The Southeast Sulawesi High Court had repeatedly tried to contact him but received no response.
Two warning letters instructing INS to return to his duties were also issued, but he continued to neglect his obligations without explanation.
The panel cited several aggravating factors. INS had failed to comply with a sanction imposed by the Supreme Court Chief Justice, which was considered to undermine the authority of the Supreme Court’s oversight; he had neglected his duties as a judge for a very long period; he had received disciplinary penalties three times, in 2016, 2022 and 2023; he had not co-operated; and he had shown no remorse.
On the other hand, the panel considered that INS’s disciplinary record was not related to the handling of cases, bribery or abuse of office. However, this did not alter its assessment that his absence from work constituted a serious disciplinary violation.
The MKH said INS’s conduct had been proven to violate the Joint Decree of the Supreme Court Chief Justice and the Judicial Commission Chairperson, Number 047/KMA/SKB/IV/2009 and Number 02/SKB/P.KY/IV/2009, on the Code of Ethics and Guidelines for Judges’ Conduct—specifically section C, point 8, on maintaining high discipline—in conjunction with Article 12(1) and (2) of the Joint Regulation of the Supreme Court and the Judicial Commission, Number 02/PB/MA/IX/2012 and Number 02/PB/P.KY/09/2012, on Guidelines for Enforcing the Code of Ethics and Guidelines for Judges’ Conduct.
“Considering the impact caused, the conduct is classified as a serious violation under Article 18(4) of the joint regulation,” Jupriyadi said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judicial-ethics-panel-dismisses-judge-ins-with-pension-rights-for-129-days-unauthorised-absence-1792493663)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5799389/mkh-berhentikan-hakim-ins-dengan-hak-pensiun-karena-mangkir-129-hari), translated from Indonesian