Judicial Commission Member Urges Sanctions Against Judges to Go Beyond Recommendations
The Judicial Commission (KY) member, Andi Muhammad Asrun, is pushing for the strengthening of his institution’s authority to directly execute sanctions against judges proven to have committed violations.
“The Judicial Commission should have the authority to impose punishments without relying on recommendations from the Supreme Court. I believe this would also reduce the administrative workload of the Supreme Court,” said Andi Muhammad Asrun during a public discussion in Makassar, South Sulawesi, on Thursday.
He expressed hope that the revision of the Judicial Commission Law would be passed this year to bolster the KY’s supervisory functions, including the power to impose sanctions on judges found guilty of light and moderate violations.
According to him, for serious ethical violations, the mechanism of the Supreme Court’s Honour Council remains necessary. This mechanism provides an opportunity for judges accused of misconduct to present a defence and submit new evidence.
Andi noted that granting the KY the authority to impose sanctions without Supreme Court recommendations could alleviate the administrative burden on the nation’s highest judicial institution.
Meanwhile, Professor Supanji Ahmad from Al Azhar University expressed support for the amendment of the Judicial Commission Law, despite acknowledging the difficulty of the process.
“Despite the many limitations in the KY’s authority, making the most of the existing powers will surely produce monumental works,” he remarked.
“There needs to be a spirit of collaboration, rather than competition. The current era requires collaboration between the KY and the Supreme Court within the context of oversight,” he added.
He noted that based on available data, only approximately 25 per cent of the KY’s recommendations are implemented by the Supreme Court.
“This indicates ineffectiveness. What are the causes? There needs to be cooperation with universities to research why the Judicial Commission’s recommendations are ineffective—whether it is due to sectoral ego or because the recommendations lack executory power. There needs to be academic clarity,” he explained.
In addition to execution authority, Supanji also encouraged strengthening the KY’s investigative powers, regarding both ethical aspects and the examination process.
“A few days ago, the Ombudsman made headlines in Indonesia with their investigation results. The KY needs to undertake similar actions to create positive momentum and foster public trust,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judicial-commission-member-urges-sanctions-against-judges-to-go-beyond-recommendations-1790877283)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5767604/anggota-ky-dorong-sanksi-hakim-tak-berhenti-pada-rekomendasi), translated from Indonesian