Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Judicial Commission Calls for Law Revision to Strengthen Oversight Powers over Judges

| Source: detikBali Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Judicial Commission Calls for Law Revision to Strengthen Oversight Powers over Judges
Image: detikBali

The Judicial Commission (KY) is calling for a revision of the Judicial Commission Law to strengthen its authority to oversee judges’ conduct. It says the current rules do not give KY a sufficiently strong position to carry out its external oversight role.

“External oversight by the Judicial Commission must have a firm legal basis to be effective,” KY Chair Abdul Chair Ramadhan said.

Abdul Chair made the remarks at an international seminar entitled ‘Reorganising Indonesia’s Judicial Governance: Making the Judicial Commission a Complement to Judicial Power for Judicial Independence’ at The Trans Resort Bali in Badung, Bali, on Thursday (15 October 2026).

According to Abdul Chair, one issue that needs to be addressed is the division of oversight powers between KY and the Supreme Court (MA). The MA conducts internal oversight through its Supervisory Board, while KY externally monitors judges’ conduct.

“The division between internal and external oversight must be clearly arranged. There must be no overlap or disharmony,” he stressed.

He said the two mechanisms need to be organised to prevent overlap, disharmony or uncertainty in the implementation of oversight. Abdul Chair also highlighted that KY recommendations are not currently final and binding.

Under the current mechanism, KY recommendations on sanctions must be submitted to the MA for follow-up. “The implementation of Judicial Commission recommendations must be certain. Otherwise, oversight will lose its force,” Abdul Chair said.

“Revising the Judicial Commission Law is a necessity and an obligation,” he added.

Abdul Chair believes stronger regulations are needed so KY can carry out its duties, functions and powers more effectively. In addition to legal constraints, he said limitations in the organisation’s structure, facilities and budget also hinder its work.

He said a reorganisation of judicial governance should not be viewed as an attempt to set KY against the MA. Oversight and judicial independence, he said, must go hand in hand.

“Strengthening the Judicial Commission does not mean weakening the Supreme Court. Rather, it is needed to build a more accountable judicial system,” he said.

Oversight is necessary to safeguard accountability and establish good, clean judicial governance, he said. Strengthening KY should therefore improve the judicial system, not take over judges’ independence in deciding cases.

The seminar was also intended to build support for the idea of KY as a complement to judicial power. Abdul Chair said a national declaration on the proposal was being planned.

“We want to build a shared understanding that the Judicial Commission is an important part of improving the system of judicial power,” Abdul Chair said.

“What we are advocating is legal certainty, effective oversight, and a clean and principled judiciary,” he concluded.

More from 15 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judicial-commission-calls-for-law-revision-to-strengthen-oversight-powers-over-judges-1792057817)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/berita/d-8708510/desak-kewenangan-pengawasan-hakim-diperkuat-komisi-yudisial-minta-revisi-uu), translated from Indonesian
Print