Judges Rule Nadiem Placed Special Staff Beyond Authority in Chromebook Procurement Case
The Jakarta Corruption Court panel has ruled that the former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Makarim, committed an abuse of authority by appointing ministerial special staff to positions that exceeded the duties and functions regulated by law.
This was stated by Judge Sunoto while reading the verdict considerations in the case of alleged corruption regarding the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM) on Tuesday (30/6).
The judge explained that, based on Presidential Regulation Number 68 of 201scale 19 concerning the Organisation of State Ministries and related regulations, ministerial special staff only have the authority to provide advice and considerations to the minister in specific fields. Special staff do not possess operational authority over Echelon I or Echelon II officials, nor are they authorised to formulate or decide on policies.
However, according to the panel of judges, trial facts show that Nadiem placed Jurist Tan, as Special Staff for Government Affairs, and Fiona Handayani, as Special Staff for Strategic Issues, in positions that exceeded their normative authority.
These considerations were based on testimony from several witnesses within the ministry. The former Director General of Early Childhood, Primary, and Secondary Education, Jumeri, stated, for instance, that Jurist Tan frequently led meetings via Zoom regarding ministerial policies. He also noted that budgeting processes and procurement policies were entrusted more to special staff than to directorate general officials.
“Jurist Tan was close to the defendant Nadiem Anwar Makarim, and what Jurist Tan conveyed represented the defendant’s words,” the judge stated, quoting witness testimony.
The panel also cited the testimony of the former Director of Junior High Schools, Purwadi Sutanto, who stated that substantive authority in drafting information and communication technology procurement policies rested largely with the minister’s special staff and the ministry’s technology team. This testimony was found to be consistent with the statements of several other internal officials.
The judge assessed that this pattern did not occur by chance but was designed before Nadiem was officially inaugurated as minister.
During the trial, Nadiem admitted that the WhatsApp group “Mas Menteri Core Tim” was formed on 28 August 2019, prior to his inauguration as minister on 23 October 2019. According to the judges, this group already included individuals who were subsequently appointed as special staff, including Jurist Tan and Fiona Handayani.
Furthermore, the panel highlighted the existence of the “Tim PAUD Dasmen” WhatsApp group which, according to witness Jumeri, had discussed education digitalisation programmes before the relevant officials were officially appointed. These facts were deemed to indicate policy planning occurring outside the formal structure of the ministry.
In addition to the abuse of authority, the panel of judges also ruled that Nadiable committed an abuse of resources by placing an external consultant, Ibrahim Arief, in a strategic position within the procurement technical team.
The judge noted that Ibrahim Arief, an information technology consultant from the Centre for Education Policy Studies and not a civil servant, was appointed to lead the “Warung Teknologi” (Wartek) Team under the Data and Information Centre of the Ministry of Education and Culture and played a significant role in drafting technical studies for the procurement of information and communication technology devices.
The panel also cited testimony from a procurement expert from the Government Goods/Services Procurement Agency (LKPP), Setyabudi Arijanta. Based on Presidential Regulation Number 16 of 2018 and its amendments, consultants from outside the ministry are not permitted to direct or appoint specific brands in the preparation of technical procurement specifications.
However, according to the trial facts considered by the panel, Ibrahim Arief actively provided technical input that directed procurement towards the Chrome OS operating system as the primary choice.
“Placing an external consultant in such a position constitutes an abuse of the resources available to the defendant in his capacity as minister,” said Judge Sunoto while reading the verdict considerations.
The Public Prosecutor had demanded a sentence of 18 years in prison and a fine of Rp1 billion for the former Minister Nadiem Makarim. Additionally, Nadiem was ordered to pay restitution totaling Rp5.6 trillion, consisting of Rp809 billion and Rp4.8 trillion. Failure to pay the restitution would result in an additional 9-year prison sentence.
The former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, was sentenced to 10 years in prison in the Chromebook procurement corruption case.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judges-rule-nadiem-placed-special-staff-beyond-authority-in-chromebook-procurement-case-1782809488)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/905825/hakim-nilai-nadiem-tempatkan-staf-khusus-melampaui-kewenangan-dalam-kasus-pengadaan-chromebook), translated from Indonesian