Judge's Dissenting Opinion in Nadiem Chromebook Corruption Case
Judge Andi Saputra has expressed a dissenting opinion in the verdict concerning the alleged corruption in the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM) for the 2020-2022 fiscal year, which involves former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Makarim.
Andi argued that Nadiem should be acquitted of all charges as the criminal elements were not proven beyond a reasonable doubt. He stated that the evidence presented in court failed to prove the existence of ‘mens rea’, or criminal intent, on the part of Nadiem in his capacity as minister.
“Considering that the sequence of factual puzzles assembled from the alignment of evidence in court has failed to reach a perfect causal conclusion that there was criminal intent on the part of the defendant as a minister to commit an unlawful act,” said Andi while reading his dissenting opinion at the Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (30/6).
He also assessed that Nadiem’s act of signing the Regulation of the Minister of Education and Culture Number 5 of 2021 cannot be qualified as a criminal act. According to him, the regulation did not lock in a specific brand but only specified the operating system.
Furthermore, Andi stated that the trial failed to find consistent evidence of a criminal conspiracy between the defendant, Nadiem, and the other defendants in the case. “The defendant, Nadiem, never explicitly or implicitly instructed Ibrahim, Mulyatsah, or Sri to commit acts of corruption. Conversely, Ibrahim, Mulyatsah, and Sri never provided any unlawful gifts to the defendant,” he noted.
Andi also addressed the alleged connection between the laptop procurement policy, state losses, and Google’s increased investment in PT GoTo. He assessed that these three events lacked a strong causal relationship.
“The occurrence of the laptop procurement policy, the existence of state losses, and the increase in Google’s share capital in PT GoTo are three events that do not possess a strong causality or cause-and-effect relationship, or at the very least, are not due to any criminal act, conflict of interest, or trading in influence by the defendant,” he said.
Based on these considerations, Andi concluded that the evidence submitted by the prosecutors was insufficient to prove criminal intent or wrongdoing by Nadiem. “Considering that the defendant is not proven legally and convincingly guilty of the criminal acts as charged in the primary and subsidiary indictments, therefore the defendant, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, must be acquitted of all such charges,” he stated.
Nadiem was sentenced to 10 years in prison and a fine of Rp1 billion in the corruption case involving the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM) for the 2020-2022 fiscal year. The court ruled that Nadiem was proven guilty of corruption as per the subsidiary indictment.
Nadiem was also ordered to pay additional compensation amounting to Rp809.5 billion. If the compensation is not paid, the penalty will be replaced by an additional 5 years of imprisonment.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judges-dissenting-opinion-in-nadiem-chromebook-corruption-case-1782816867)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260630165501-12-1375188/pertimbangan-hakim-andi-saputra-dissenting-opinion-vonis-nadiem), translated from Indonesian