Judge's Considerations Nullify Suspect Status of Former Condongcatur Village Head Reno
The panel of judges in the pretrial hearing over the alleged misuse of village land in plot 88, Pringwulung, Condongcatur, Depok, Sleman, has explained its reasons for accepting the petition that resulted in the nullification of the suspect status of former Condongcatur village head Reno Candra Sangaji (RCS).
The pretrial hearing was held in the Garuda courtroom of the Yogyakarta District Court this morning. In the ruling read out by presiding judge Sri Sulastuti, the respondent in the case, the Yogyakarta High Prosecutor’s Office, was deemed unable to prove its case through the evidence presented during the proceedings.
According to the judge, the Yogyakarta High Prosecutor’s Office never submitted the physical document or a copy of the Investigation Order, namely Number Print-261/M.4/Fd.1/02/2025 and Print-308/M.4/Fd.1/02/2025, as documentary evidence in court.
The judge stated that an investigation order is an authentic document that serves as the formal legal basis for an investigator to carry out legal actions, including gathering two pieces of valid evidence. Without the investigation order being presented in court, the judge could not assess the authority of the officials, the clarity of the articles applied, or the formal procedures followed.
“The court legally considers that the respondent had no legal basis in the form of an investigation order when naming the suspect,” the panel of judges said during the hearing on Wednesday (26/8).
As a result, the judge ruled that the Audit Report on State Financial Loss Calculation, which had been used as evidence, no longer had binding legal force because it originated from an investigation process that was legally unfounded from the outset.
“The legality of the investigator’s actions in determining evidence has become baseless,” the panel of judges stated.
On the grounds of this flawed formal procedure, the panel of judges partially granted Reno’s petition. In the same hearing, the panel also granted the pretrial motion of another suspect in the case, a former village security officer identified by the initial K.
“Granting the pretrial petition in part,” the panel’s ruling read.
The judge also declared that the naming of the pretrial petitioners as suspects, based on Suspect Determination Letters Number TAP-267/M.4/Fd.1/06/2026 dated 30 June 2026 and TAP-268/M.4/Fd.1/06/2026 dated 30 June 2026, was legally invalid.
Nevertheless, the detention already served by the suspects remains lawful. However, with the pretrial ruling, the judge ordered that both suspects must be released from detention.
“Releasing the suspects or pretrial petitioners from detention, ordering the pretrial respondent to release the suspects or pretrial petitioners from detention immediately after the ruling is pronounced,” the panel of judges explained.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judges-considerations-nullify-suspect-status-of-former-condongcatur-village-head-reno-1787730674)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8635037/pertimbangan-hakim-gugurkan-status-tersangka-reno-eks-lurah-concat), translated from Indonesian