Judges' Considerations in Sentencing Nadiem Makarim to 10 Years for Chromebook Corruption
The Panel of Judges at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court (Tipikor) has revealed several aggravating and mitigating considerations in delivering the sentence against the former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Anwar Makarim, in the corruption case involving the procurement of Chromebook laptops and Chrome Device Management (CDM).
The Chairman of the Panel, Purwanto S. Abdullah, stated that one of the aggravating factors was that the criminal act committed by Nadiem was planned, structured, and systematic, resulting in massive state losses. “The act was carried out in a planned, structured, and systematic manner, causing very large state financial losses and having a wide impact on the implementation of education, particularly for children in disadvantaged, frontier, and outermost regions,” Purwanto said while reading the verdict at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (30/6).
The panel also assessed that Nadiem’s actions contravened the commitment of the government and society to eradicate corruption. As a minister, Nadiem was deemed to have been expected to serve as a role model, rather than abusing his official authority. “The defendant’s actions contradict the commitment of the government and society in eradicating corruption. The defendant, as a minister who should have been a role model, instead abused his official authority,” the judge stated.
Furthermore, Nadiem’s affluent economic condition was considered an aggravating factor. According to the panel of judges, there was no economic necessity that drove the defendant to commit the corruption. “The defendant’s economic situation is very sufficient, so there was no economic need driving his actions,” said Pursebaya.
On the other hand, the panel of judges also considered several mitigating circumstances. The judges stated that Nadiem had no prior criminal record, behaved politely and cooperatively during the trial, and was previously known as a figure who contributed to the fields of education and technology.
Based on all these considerations, the panel of judges sentenced Nadiem to 10 years in prison. Additionally, he was ordered to pay a fine of Rp1 billion, with a subsidiary of 190 days of imprisonment, and restitution of Rp809 billion. If the restitution is not paid, Nadiem will face an additional five years of imprisonment.
Previously, the public prosecutor had demanded a prison sentence of 18 years for Nadiem, a fine of Rp1 billion with a subsidiary of 190 days, and restitution amounting to approximately Rp5.68 trillion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judges-considerations-in-sentencing-nadiem-makarim-to-10-years-for-chromebook-corruption-1782816660)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/905859/ini-pertimbangan-hakim-menjatuhkan-vonis-10-tahun-kepada-nadiem-makarim), translated from Indonesian