Judge Warns Dr Tifa’s Lawyer: ‘If You Cannot Behave, You Can Leave!’
A judge reprimanded the lawyer for defendant Tifauzia Tyassuma, known as Dr Tifa, in a case concerning alleged slander over the diploma of Indonesia’s seventh president, Joko Widodo (Jokowi). The judge said Tifa’s lawyer could leave the courtroom if she could not maintain order.
The latest hearing to examine witnesses in Tifa’s trial was held at the East Jakarta District Court on Thursday (5 November 2026). Jokowi appeared as a witness.
At the start, the prosecutor read out posts from the @DokterTifa account that were alleged to contain claims that Jokowi’s diploma was fake. Jokowi was asked to confirm the posts. Tifa’s lawyer, Roy, interrupted the exchange between the prosecutor and Jokowi to ask who owned the account.
“Sorry, whose account is that?” Tifa’s lawyer asked.
“With the court’s permission, counsel should pay attention; we have already stated that,” the prosecutor replied.
The judge said the prosecutor had already identified the account and told Tifa’s lawyer not to interrupt.
“It has already been stated several times. If you keep interrupting, we will never get through this. Just listen first. This has already been said,” the judge said.
“This is the @DokterTifa account, Your Honours. If the defendant later wants to deny that it is her account, she can respond when it is her turn,” the prosecutor said.
“We will give you time. When you ask questions, the defendant will also have an opportunity to respond at the end, including during the defence. Listen first; it has already been said that this is Dr Tifa’s account,” the judge said.
Jokowi said he had reported 31 posts over allegations concerning his diploma. He said five of the 31 pieces of evidence were posts from Tifa’s account.
As the prosecutor continued questioning Jokowi, Tifa’s lawyer again interrupted, saying she wanted to offer the panel of judges a suggestion.
“For the next post, Your Honour, the witness objected to five posts from X and one from YouTube,” the prosecutor said before being interrupted by Tifa’s lawyer.
“Your Honours, my suggestion, so that we can be treated fairly, is this: how can we respond to this if we do not have the documents? It was explained earlier that all trial documents should be provided to us,” the lawyer said.
“With the court’s permission, this is an accusation,” the prosecutor said, before being interrupted again.
“So this is my suggestion to the panel, if I may—my suggestion,” Tifa’s lawyer said.
The judge said the lawyer did not need to make suggestions and that her objection would be recorded in the hearing minutes.
“There is no need to make suggestions. I have instructed the prosecutor to continue. If your objection is rejected, we will record what you have said in the minutes,” the judge said.
“So the panel is being unfair, then. This is not about recording it; we are asking for justice. You should treat us fairly. We should have all the documents. We do not have them, only—” Tifa’s lawyer said, before the judge cut her off.
The judge reprimanded the lawyer and said she could leave the courtroom if she did not behave.
“If you do not comply and cannot maintain order, you may leave,” the judge said.
“We are behaving properly, that is why—” Tifa’s lawyer said, before being interrupted again.
“Go ahead. Do not comment to the visitors in the courtroom! We will continue the hearing and listen to this. It is there; you can check it too,” the judge said.
The judge also admonished people in the public gallery, said the lawyer’s objection would be recorded, and instructed the prosecutor to continue questioning Jokowi.
“If you are simply objecting for the sake of it, fine, I will record your objection, but I have ordered the hearing to continue. Please proceed,” the judge said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-warns-dr-tifas-lawyer-if-you-cannot-behave-you-can-leave-1793886680)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8740244/hakim-tegur-pengacara-dr-tifa-kalau-tidak-tertib-boleh-keluar), translated from Indonesian