Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Judge Says Noel Ebenezer's Achievements Deserve State Appreciation

| Source: VIVA.co.id Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Judge Says Noel Ebenezer's Achievements Deserve State Appreciation
Image: VIVA.co.id

The panel of judges has expressed the view that the achievements of the defendant, Immanuel Ebeneber Gerungan, during his term as Deputy Minister of Manpower (Wamenaker) for the 2024–2025 period deserve appreciation from the state, without absolving him of criminal responsibility for his actions regarding Occupational Health and Safety (K3) within the Ministry of Manpower.

Presiding Judge Nur Sari Baktiana revealed that this consideration was made after reviewing the defendant’s defence and his bureaucratic track record during his tenure. “The matters presented by the defendant are true and real, and thus deserve appreciation from the state, without negating the criminal liability for the defendant’s proven actions, as established in the legal considerations,” the Presiding Judge stated during the verdict reading at the Corruption Court of the Central Jakarta District Court on Thursday.

According to the panel of judges, state appreciation for Noel should be granted considering that his actions while serving as Deputy Minister represented the presence of the state in protecting the rights of citizens in the field of employment.

The Presiding Judge revealed that Noel proved his capacity as a representative of the state through tangible policy breakthroughs, specifically the issuance of two important circular letters in a short period: the prohibition of the practice of withholding educational certificates and the removal of discriminatory recruitment requirements.

From a juridical perspective, the panel of judges assessed that Noel’s actions were not merely administrative matters, but a manifestation of the state’s stance to restore dignity and provide legal certainty for millions of Indonesian workers. For decades, these workers were held hostage by unfair systems or marginalised due to age limits, physical appearance, or marital status—factors irrelevant to job competence.

Consequently, although Noel has admitted his mistakes and expressed deep regret for his lack of diligence in upholding his official duties, the panel of judges believes that his series of achievements and genuine service, which have impacted the livelihoods of millions of labourers, should not be ignored in the sentencing.

The Presiding Judge stated that true justice must clearly weigh the offences committed against the magnitude of the positive contributions Noel has provided to the nation and the state during his tenure. Therefore, the panel of judges considers Noel’s various services as Deputy Minister—representing the tangible presence of the state amidst the hardships of the common people—as a factor worthy of consideration to mitigate the imposition of a proportional sentence, rather than mere retribution.

Tags: berita

More from 4 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-says-noel-ebenezers-achievements-deserve-state-appreciation-1780602650)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1903415-hakim-sebut-prestasi-noel-ebenezer-perlu-diapresiasi), translated from Indonesian
Print