Judge Rules Search, Arrest, and Detention of Roy Suryo Unlawful
A South Jakarta District Court judge has ruled that the search, arrest, and detention of KMRT Roy Suryo by the Jakarta Metropolitan Police were unlawful. Judge I Ketut Darpawan stated that the forced measures were procedurally flawed.
“Granting the Petitioner’s Praperadilan motion in part,” the judge said while reading the verdict for case number 99/Pid.Pra/2026/PN JKT.SEL on Tuesday (7/7).
The judge declared the search conducted by the Jakarta Metropolitan Police, based on a warrant dated 18 June 2026, was unlawful. Although the search had received permission from the head of the Tangerang District Court, the judge considered other formal aspects. The reason for the search, as stated in the request for permission, contradicted what actually occurred. The permission was granted because the location was suspected of hiding evidence, but in practice, the search was conducted to make an arrest.
“The search was no longer for the purpose of finding and seizing evidence,” the judge noted.
The judge also ruled the arrest of Roy Suryo, based on an arrest warrant dated 19 June 2026, was unlawful. Roy and his family had refused the arrest. Since being named a suspect on 7 November 2025, the investigation had proceeded without Roy ever being arrested, and there was no evidence he attempted to flee or obstruct the legal process.
“Considering that the search and arrest actions by the Respondent [Jakarta Metropolitan Police] were procedurally and materially flawed, it is therefore appropriate to declare these actions unlawful,” the judge stated.
Furthermore, the judge declared Roy Suryo’s detention unlawful. The judge emphasised that investigators must adhere to procedural law and a Constitutional Court ruling regarding the subjective and objective conditions for detention. The subjective condition, which requires a concern that the suspect might flee, destroy evidence, or repeat the offence, was not met in Roy’s case, as he had been cooperative throughout the investigation.
“Considering that the detention by the Respondent against the Petitioner did not fulfil the subjective requirement, it is therefore appropriate to declare the detention unlawful,” the judge concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-rules-search-arrest-and-detention-of-roy-suryo-unlawful-1783414431)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260707142353-12-1377886/hakim-penggeledahan-penangkapan-dan-penahanan-roy-suryo-tidak-sah), translated from Indonesian