Judge Rules Police Actions Against Roy Suryo Unlawful
The single judge of the South Jakarta District Court, I Ketut Darpawan, has revealed the considerations underlying the decision to partially grant Roy Suryo’s pre-trial petition.
“First, regarding the search and arrest actions carried as carried out by the respondent against the petitioner,” stated Judge I Ketut Darpawan on Tuesday, 7 July 2026.
The judge noted that the core issue under consideration was the legality of the search, arrest, and detention of Roy Suryo.
The judge assessed that although the Metro Jaya Regional Police had obtained a search warrant from the Tangerang District Court, there were discrepancies between the reasons provided in the permit application and the actual execution in the field.
“The Chairperson of the Tangerang District Court granted permission to the respondent to conduct a search because the house or closed premises mentioned in the letter was suspected by the respondent to be a hiding place for evidence. However, in practice, the search was conducted to carry out the arrest of the petitioner,” he said.
The judge also stated that Roy Suryo had been cooperative during the investigation and there were no circumstances indicating obstacles for investigators to transfer the case to the prosecutor.
“The use of search and arrest measures by the respondent, without being able to prove justifiable reasons according to the judge, is an arbitrary action,” he remarked.
Regarding the detention, the judge noted that Roy Suryo had been subject to mandatory reporting since being named a suspect on 7 November 2025 until 18 June 2026 without ever being formally detained. Consequently, the judge ruled that the subjective requirements for detention were not met. However, the judge rejected Roy Suryo’s request to declare the entire investigation file invalid.
The judge emphasised that the invalidity of the search, arrest, and detention does not automatically render the investigation files invalid. Furthermore, the request for the court to prohibit the public prosecutor from issuing a detention warrant was rejected as it falls outside the authority of a pre-trial hearing.
It was previously reported that Roy Suryo achieved a partial victory in the pre-trial hearing held at the South Jakarta District Court on Tuesday, 7 July 2026. Single judge I Ketut Darpawan declared that several coercive measures taken by the Metro Jaya Police investigators against Roy Suryo, including the search, arrest, and detention, were unlawful. The verdict was delivered during the pre-trial hearing examining the legality of the investigators’ actions in the case involving Roy Suryo.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-rules-police-actions-against-roy-suryo-unlawful-1783432431)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1911736-alasan-polda-metro-kalah-di-praperadilan-roy-suryo-terkuak-penggeledahan-dinilai-sewenang-wenang), translated from Indonesian