Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Judge Rules on Fate of Online Drivers Who Could Be Suddenly Dismissed

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Judge Rules on Fate of Online Drivers Who Could Be Suddenly Dismissed
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Uber Technologies once operated in Indonesia, offering online taxi and motorbike-hailing services. However, Uber was forced to exit the South-East Asian market, including Indonesia, in April 2018.

Uber subsequently handed over all its business operations in South-East Asia to Grab. Since then, Uber has focused on developing its business in key markets such as the United States and several European countries.

Uber has also been among the ride-hailing companies that quickly adapted to electric taxi services and even driverless robotaxis. However, the company has frequently faced legal problems relating to its innovations and business decisions.

Some time ago, Uber faced a legal case with the New York City government. Together with its rival Lyft, Uber was required to give 14 days’ notice before deactivating drivers from their platforms. An exemption was granted for drivers committing serious violations.

The New York City government’s order was set down in a law enacted in January 2026. Under the rule, ride-hailing services such as Uber and Lyft could also be required to rehire drivers deactivated since 2019, purely because they had not received such notice.

In a separate lawsuit filed in June 2026, Uber and Lyft argued that the law violated their rights to fair legal procedures and freedom of speech as guaranteed by the US Constitution.

They said the law risked damaging their reputation and good name, whilst leaving problematic drivers — including those accused of sexual misconduct — operating on the roads.

Judge Rules in Favour of Uber and Lyft

After the case proceeded for some time, a federal judge finally ruled that New York City cannot bar Uber and Lyft from deactivating their driver partners from their apps without notice. The new ruling states that the new New York City regulation is unconstitutional.

US District Judge Gregory Woods in Manhattan said in a written ruling on Tuesday (21 July 2026) that the city regulation passed earlier this year benefits only a small fraction of drivers, whilst interfering with the ride-hailing companies’ right to oversee the safety of their platforms.

“Uber and Lyft have shown that the law protects a small group of drivers and does not advance the broader social or economic interests required by the US Constitution to permit a serious breach of their contracts,” Woods wrote in his ruling, as quoted by Reuters on Thursday (23 July 2026).

The judge issued a preliminary injunction preventing New York City from enforcing penalties on Uber and Lyft, which were due to take effect on 28 July, pending the outcome of the joint lawsuit filed by the companies last month.

Lyft said in a statement issued by a spokesperson: “We are pleased the court recognised the serious safety concerns at the heart of this challenge.”

Separately, Uber spokesperson Josh Gold said: “The opinion affirms that fairness for drivers and safety for passengers can and must go hand in hand.”

The New York City Law Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

More from 23 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-rules-on-fate-of-online-drivers-who-could-be-suddenly-dismissed-1784800341)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20260723131928-37-753241/hakim-putuskan-nasib-driver-online-bisa-dipecat-tiba-tiba), translated from Indonesian
Print