Judge Rules Acid Attack on Andrie Yunus Not a Military Intelligence Operation
The Panel of Judges has declared that the acid attack carried out by four TNI personnel against the Vice Coordinator of KontraS, Andrie Yunus, was not a structured, systematic, or massive intelligence operation.
During the trial, member of the panel, Navy Major (Law) Zainal Abidin, stated that an expert witness had testified that strategic intelligence operations are not built upon personal anger, but rather on calculations of national interest. The judges emphasised this expert opinion, concluding that the defendants’ actions had no connection to the involvement of a command structure.
In the case of the alleged assault against Andrie, four defendants have been sentenced to prison terms ranging from one year and six months to three years. The defendants—Sergeant Two Edi Sudarko (three years), Lieutenant One Budhi Hariyantow Widhi (two years and six months), Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetya (two years), and Lieutenant Sami Lakka (one year and six months)—were penalised. Additionally, Edi and Budhi were handed the supplementary penalty of dishonourable discharge from military service.
Judge Zainal clarified that for an action to be classified as an official intelligence operation, it must be proven to serve a strategic national purpose, involving orders or authorisation from a command structure, operational planning, operational support, execution control, evaluation mechanisms, and accountability. As these elements were absent, it is professionally and doctrinally difficult to categorise the act as an official intelligence operation.
The court found that the four TNI personnel had planned the acid attack with the intent to provide a ‘lesson’ and a ‘deterrent effect’ to prevent Andrie from disparaging the TNI institution. The tension arose following an incident on 16 March 2025, when the KontraS activist interrupted a meeting regarding the revision of the TNI Law in Jakarta. Other grievances included Andrie’s lawsuit against the TNI Law at the Constitutional Court, his allegations of TNI intimidation at the KontraS office, and his involvement in narratives regarding the August 2025 riots.
The court ruled that the planned use of acid, which the defendants knew could cause severe burns, was an improper act for TNI members. The defendants were found guilty of violating Article 467, paragraph (1) juncto paragraph (2) in conjunction with Article 20 letter C of the National Penal Code.
The Military Prosecutor is currently considering an appeal against the sentences of the four BAIS TNI soldiers involved. Meanwhile, legal observers have noted the lack of additional dismissal demands for all defendants, arguing that the prosecution’s initial demands were disproportionate to the gravity of the crime.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-rules-acid-attack-on-andrie-yunus-not-a-military-intelligence-operation-1781096015)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/899054/hakim-penyiraman-air-keras-andrie-yunus-bukan-operasi-intelijen), translated from Indonesian