Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Judge Reveals Reasons for Granting Roy Suryo's Pretrial Motion

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Judge Reveals Reasons for Granting Roy Suryo's Pretrial Motion
Image: CNN Indonesia

Sole judge at the South Jakarta District Court, I Ketut Darpawan, declared that the legal actions of Polda Metro Jaya regarding the search, arrest, and detention of KMRT Roy Suryo Notodiprojo were formally flawed and must be declared invalid by law. The judge partially granted Roy’s pretrial motion in case number 99/Pid.Pra/2026/PN JKT.SEL. Only one of Roy’s petitions was not granted, namely the request for the restoration of his dignity and reputation.

The judge stated that the search conducted by Polda Metro Jaya based on a warrant for the search of a house and other closed places dated 18 June 2026 was invalid. Although the search had obtained permission from the head of the Tangerang District Court, the judge considered another important formal aspect, namely the reason for the search, which turned out to be contradictory between what was stated in the permit application and what was actually carried out. The judge revealed that the Tangerang District Court head granted permission for the search because the location was suspected by Polda Metro Jaya as a hiding place for evidence based on the examination of a suspect. However, in its execution, as argued by Polda Metro Jaya, the search was conducted to make an arrest for the purpose of handing over the suspect and evidence to the Public Prosecutor because the case file was complete. The judge noted the search was no longer for the purpose of finding and seizing evidence. The judge added that a search must adhere to applicable rules, including the presence of two witnesses and must be attended by the village head or neighbourhood head. The judge understood that investigations are full of challenges and obstacles, but these are casuistic, and not every case has the same constraints such as a perpetrator fleeing or destroying evidence. Based on trial facts corroborated by Polda Metro Jaya’s testimony, Roy was proven to be cooperative. The judge stated that materially, there was no urgency to conduct a search with the aim of arresting the Petitioner.

Regarding the arrest, the judge ruled that Roy Suryo’s arrest based on an arrest warrant dated 19 June 2026 was also invalid. The judge noted that Roy and his family refused the arrest. Since Roy was named a suspect on 7 November 2025, the investigation process continued and Roy was never arrested. Furthermore, there was no evidence that Roy attempted to evade the legal process. The judge concluded that because there were formal and material defects in the search and arrest actions carried out by the Respondent, it was proper for these actions to be declared invalid.

Subsequently, the judge declared Roy’s detention based on a detention warrant dated 19 June 2026 invalid. The judge reminded investigators to adhere to applicable criminal procedure law and consider the Constitutional Court ruling which contains formal, material, subjective, and objective requirements when conducting a detention. The formal requirement includes providing a detention warrant with a copy to the family stating the suspect’s identity, the reason for detention, a brief description of the alleged case, and the place of detention. The material requirement is that it is carried out on a suspect alleged to have committed a crime based on at least two pieces of evidence. The subjective requirement is the existence of circumstances raising concern that the suspect will flee, destroy or eliminate evidence, or repeat the criminal act. The objective requirement is that the suspect is alleged to have committed a crime punishable by 5 years or more in prison. In Roy’s case, based on facts revealed in the trial, his detention was deemed not to meet the subjective requirement. The judge emphasised that although the search, arrest, and detention actions were problematic, this did not automatically invalidate the entire investigation file. The case is not over, especially as Roy is also challenging the process of his suspect designation by Polda Metro Jaya at the South Jakarta District Court, with a hearing scheduled for Friday, 10 July 2026.

More from 8 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-reveals-reasons-for-granting-roy-suryos-pretrial-motion-1783468295)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260708060837-12-1378145/alasan-hakim-kabulkan-praperadilan-roy-suryo), translated from Indonesian
Print