Judge rejects pretrial motion of three TTU DPRD members in Dr Icha case
Kupang (ANTARA) - A judge at the Kupang District Court, East Nusa Tenggara (NTT), has rejected the pretrial motion filed by three members of the North Central Timor (TTU) Regional House of Representatives (DPRD), who were questioning their designation as suspects in the alleged intimidation case of the late Dr Eliza Princila Utami Pakaenundoni, also known as Dr Icha.
The verdict was delivered by the sole judge of the Kupang District Court, Jantiani Longli Naetasi, in case Number 7/Pid.Pra/2026/PN Kpg, on Tuesday (6/10).
“Adjudicating, rejecting the pretrial motion of the petitioners,” said Jantiani while reading the verdict.
The three TTU DPRD members who filed the pretrial motion are Therensius Lazakar, Norbertus Tubani, and Veronika Lake.
The evidence includes findings from witness examinations, documents, and physical evidence obtained through legally authorised seizure processes. The judge also ruled that there was no proof that the evidence used by investigators was obtained unlawfully.
“The Respondent’s designation of the petitioners as suspects was based on at least two valid pieces of preliminary evidence,” Jantiani stated.
Regarding the psychiatric diagnosis contested by the petitioners, the judge ruled that the relevance of such a diagnosis to the alleged criminal offence is a matter of the main case that must be examined during the full trial.
The judge also rejected the petitioners’ argument that the examination of the DPRD members should have been preceded by written approval from the Governor of NTT. The petitioners based this argument on Constitutional Court Decision Number 76/PUU-XII/2014. However, the judge ruled that the decision does not automatically require the examination of regency/city DPRD members to be conducted only after obtaining written approval from the governor.
The judge considered that following that Constitutional Court decision, the Law on MPR, DPR, DPD, and DPRD (UU MD3) underwent amendments in 2018 and 2019. These amendments to the UU MD3 did not adopt provisions requiring the examination of regency/city DPRD members to be based on written approval from the governor.
“As it is not regulated in the amendments to the MD3 Law, the principle of lex posterior derogat legi priori applies, which establishes that newer law overrides older law,” said Jantinian.
The judge assessed that the considerations in Constitutional Court Decision Number 76/PUU-XII/2014 that were not adopted in the MD3 Law amendments were obiter dictum, not ratio decidendi. Therefore, although the Constitutional Court decision is final and binding, the judge stated that those specific considerations cannot serve as a basis to claim that the examination of the petitioners must obtain written approval from the governor.
The judge subsequently rejected the petitioners’ objection regarding the suspect designation letters, which they claimed lacked a brief description of the case. In this matter, investigators issued Suspect Designation Letters Number S.Tap.Tsk/15/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum dated 27 August 2026 for Therensius Lazakar, as well as letters numbered S.Tap.Tsk/16/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum for Norbertus Tubani and S.Tap.Tsk/17/VIII/2026/Ditreskrimum for Veronika Lake.
According to the judge, all three letters contained the identity of the suspects, the chronology of the case, the rights of the suspects, and notification of the suspect designation to the relevant parties.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-rejects-pretrial-motion-of-three-ttu-dprd-members-in-dr-icha-case-1791277573)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5773357/hakim-tolak-praperadilan-tiga-anggota-dprd-ttu-kasus-dricha), translated from Indonesian