Judge Perplexed by Former Director General's Vague Testimony in Ex-Minister's Hajj Corruption Trial
The presiding judge expressed bewilderment regarding the testimony of the former Director General of Hajj and Umrah Organistion (PHU) at the Ministry of Religious Affairs, Hilman Latief, during the trial concerning the 2023-2024 Hajj quota corruption case. The judge noted his confusion when Hilman responded with the phrase ‘it could be’ to several inquiries.
The trial was held at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court on Thursday (24/9/2026). The prosecution initially questioned Hilman regarding a photograph showing him with Isfah Abidal Azis, a former special staff member to Yaqut, and several other Ministry of Religious Affairs officials. The prosecution sought to clarify whether there were discussions regarding Director General Decree (Kepdirjen) Number 240 of 2023 during that meeting.
While Hilman admitted that a meeting took place and that he was reminded to electronically sign the decree, he expressed doubt regarding whether any detailed discussions regarding the substance of the regulation occurred. When asked if he was certain whether the request to sign was made, Hilman replied, ‘It could be,’ prompting immediate follow-up questions from the judge.
The judge pressed Hilman to clarify the meaning of ‘it could be’ and asked if he remembered the specific event. Although Hilman claimed to remember the event, he remained uncertain about the specific details of the conversation. The judge pointed out the discrepancy between Hilman’s current vague testimony and the extensive, detailed explanations recorded in his official police interrogation report (BAP), which included philosophical justifications regarding justice.
As the testimony continued, Hilman admitted he could not recall the specifics of the lengthy explanations found in the BAP. When the judge presented the BAP for verification, Hilman confirmed that the initials on the document were indeed his. In a moment of frustration regarding the conflicting accounts between the witness and the investigators, the judge jokingly remarked that the investigators might be ‘hallucinating’ or ‘making things up.’
The defendants in this case include former Minister of Religious Affairs Yaqut Cholil Qoumas, former special staff member Isfah Abidal Azis, the Operational Director of PT Makassar Toraja (Maktour) Ismail Adham, and the Commissioner of PT Raudah Eksati Utama and Chairman of the Kesthuri Association, Asrul Azis Taba. Prosecutors allege that the defendants’ actions regarding the distribution of additional Hajj quotas resulted in state losses amounting to approximately Rp 622,090,207,166.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-perplexed-by-former-director-generals-vague-testimony-in-ex-ministers-hajj-corruption-trial-1790244450)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8677503/hakim-heran-eks-dirjen-haji-jawab-bisa-jadi-di-sidang-eks-menag-yaqut), translated from Indonesian