Judge Immediately Closes Court After Reading Nadiem Verdict, Observer Says It Was Discretion to Maintain Order
The decision by the Central Jakarta District Court panel of judges to immediately close the trial after reading the verdict for former Education and Culture Minister Nadiem Makarim has ignited controversy. Public attention has focused on the fact that the defendant was not given the opportunity to respond or state his position directly before the court.
Central Jakarta District Court spokesperson M. Firman Akbar previously spoke out to quell the polemic. According to Firman, the panel’s action was not a fatal violation. “In judicial practice, it is not a problem if it is not asked,” Firman said in Jakarta on Thursday (2/7/2026).
Prosecution and judicial observer Fajar Trio assessed that the panel’s move to immediately close the trial was a form of discretion to avoid mass escalation. “We must look at the reality on the ground objectively. When the courtroom is filled with emotional supporters, giving the defendant a stage to respond spontaneously to the verdict is actually very dangerous. The judge’s action to immediately close the trial was a correct preventive measure to maintain public order and prevent contempt of court,” Fajar said when contacted on Thursday (2/7/2026).
Fajar added that in mass psychology, group emotions are easily ignited by verbal stimulation in a public space. Postponing the debate in the courtroom was considered the most rational choice. He invited the public to view the judge’s decision from a humanitarian perspective. According to him, a criminal verdict, regardless of the sentence, is a heavy psychological blow for anyone sitting in the defendant’s chair.
“There is a humanist aspect that often escapes the attention of observers. A person who has just heard a verdict is in a psychologically vulnerable condition or a state of shock. Forcing the defendant to immediately speak or make a crucial legal decision under the gaze of hundreds of emotional supporters is inhumane. That is not a healthy space for thinking,” he said. For Fajar, the judge’s action to remove the defendant from the chaotic courtroom atmosphere actually provides psychological protection so that the defendant is not burdened with appearing brave to satisfy the expectations of the crowd.
This responsive step by the panel of judges is also in line with the direction of national legal politics, which has just entered an era of major transformation. “The enactment of Law Number 20 of 2025 concerning the Criminal Procedure Code (New KUHAP) on 2 January 2026, brings a paradigm shift from a rigid and retributive approach to a humanist, measured judicial approach that prioritises due process of law,” he said.
Fajar explained that in the spirit of the New KUHAP, the role of the advocate or legal counsel is increasingly strengthened as the main pillar of legal representation. “The New KUHAP (Law 20/2025) paradigmatically prioritises judicial efficiency and strengthening the role of advocates. The defendant’s procedural rights do not always have to be physically articulated by the defendant’s own words in court if the situation is not conducive. The lawyer has full authority to safeguard these rights within the 7-day grace period guaranteed by law,” Fajar stated.
Thus, not asking for the defendant’s stance amidst a crowd of supporters is not a constitutional violation. “This step is instead considered a real portrait of law in action in 2026, where legal certainty, the defendant’s psychological protection, and courtroom order are managed intelligently and in a modern way in the court of law,” he concluded.
It is known that the verdict hearing for Nadiem Makarim at the Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (30/6/2026) was marked by protests from the defendant’s legal team. After reading the verdict, the panel of judges stood up and prepared to leave the courtroom. Nadiem’s legal team immediately raised an interruption. One of Nadiem’s lawyers, Ari Yusuf Amir, questioned the panel’s decision, which he felt did not give his client the opportunity to state his position on the verdict. “No opportunity given? Your Honour, we are not given the opportunity?” Ari said in the courtroom. He then reiterated his objection, stating that a stage of the trial had been missed. “Your Honour, Your Honour, there is a missed procedure, which is giving the defendant the opportunity to state his position,” Ari said. However, the interruption was not responded to as the panel of judges continued to leave the courtroom.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-immediately-closes-court-after-reading-nadiem-verdict-observer-says-it-was-discretion-to-maintain-order-1782982246)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/906682/hakim-langsung-tutup-persidangan-setelah-bacakan-vonis-nadiem-pengamat-diskresi-untuk-jaga-ketertiban), translated from Indonesian