Judge Highlights Andrie Yunus' Absence in Acid Attack Trial
The Panel of Judges at Military Court II-08 Jakarta has highlighted the decision of the Vice Coordinator of External Affairs at KontraS, Andrie Yunus, not to provide testimony during the trial regarding the acid attack incident involving him.
In the considerations for the verdict against four members of the TNI Strategic Intelligence Agency (BAIS) Headquarters Detachment who were defendants, member judge Navy Major (KH) M. Zainal Abidin stated that the panel had hoped from the beginning that Andrie would provide testimony to complete the facts revealed during the trial. The judges deemed the victim’s testimony essential to provide a more complete picture of the event that caused Andrie to suffer severe injuries and permanent blindness in his right eye.
However, Andrie was previously known to be unwilling to attend or provide testimony online. This stance was noted by the panel of judges in their verdict considerations. “The panel of judges considers that Andrie Yunus’s attitude has undermined the dignity of the court,” said Zainal at Military Court II-08 Jakarta on Wednesday.
Nevertheless, Andrie’s decision not to provide testimony during the trial has been explained several times by legal counsel and civil society organisations monitoring the case. They argue that this stance cannot be separated from Andrie’s experience as a victim and his views on the ongoing judicial process.
“The panel of judges initially assessed and understood this situation; however, in this instance, Mr Andrie Yunus, in addition to neglecting his obligation, has also given the impression of being contrary to the trial process and has provided a negative stigma by expressing distrust in the judicial process in the military court, even appearing to disrespect a legitimate process provided by the state,” the judge stated.
On the other hand, Andrie’s decision not to participate in the trial can be understood within the context of his experience as a victim. Since the beginning of the legal process, Andrie and several legal representatives have expressed doubts regarding the effectiveness of the military justice mechanism in uncovering the full sequence of events and the parties responsible.
While still undergoing recovery following the attack, Andrie has repeatedly stated that his primary focus is to ensure the case is handled thoroughly and accountably. In the view of his supporters, the decision not to testify is not merely a rejection of the legal process, but an expression of distrust arising from his experience and critical assessment of the current system.
Despite these differing views, the trial proceeded to the verdict. The panel of judges declared that four members of BAIS TNI were proven legally and convincingly guilty of committing premeditated assault resulting in severe injury to Andrie Yunus.
Defendant I, Sergeant Two Edi Sudarko, was sentenced to three years in prison and an additional penalty of dishonourable discharge from military service. Defendant II, First Lieutenant Budhi Hariyanto Widhi, was sentenced to two years and six months in prison and dismissed from military service.
Meanwhile, Defendant III, Captain Nandala Dwi Prasetyo, was sentenced to two years in prison, and Defendant IV, First Lieutenant Sami Lakka, was sentenced to one year and six months in prison.
The judges ruled that Edi Sudarko and Budili Hariyanto were the perpetrators who directly poured the acid on the victim, thus receiving heavier sentences. The sentences for Nandala and Sami were handed down considering their respective roles and levels of involvement in the case.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/judge-highlights-andrie-yunus-absence-in-acid-attack-trial-1781077940)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/898950/hakim-soroti-ketidakhadiran-andrie-yunus-dalam-persidangan-kasus-penyiraman-air-keras), translated from Indonesian